November 6, 2009
Toyota workers in Buffalo talking union

CHARLESTON, W.Va. -- Some workers at the Toyota manufacturing plant in Buffalo are talking to their fellow employees about getting union representation at the plant that makes engines and transmissions.

Post a Comment
YOU MUST FOLLOW THESE RULES TO POST A COMMENT:

  • Keep it clean. Comments that are obscene, sexually explicit, racist or offensive will be removed. If you wouldn’t say it to your mother, don’t post it here.
  • Be civil. Don’t threaten to hurt anyone. Personal attacks, insults or harassment of any kind are subject to removal.
  • Be truthful. Don’t lie about a situation or person.
  • Keep it brief. Keep your comment to one post. Redundant or multiple posts in a row aren’t allowed.
  • Stay on task. Stick to the topics relevant to the story and discussion.
  • Let us know about offensive comments. Click the “Report Abuse” button if you think a comment is against the rules.
  • Login/Register to comment on this story.
    Posted By: SamCogar (4:48pm 11-14-2009)
    Report Abuse


    You have background, you have the ability to acquire; you just refuse to.

    4GOD, was that directed at me. If so, then you are sadly mistaken.

    Don’t include me in with the current crop of High School Science Educators, I was trained in the “old school” back in 59/62.

    And yes, I have the knowledge and the ability and I applied said. And I could talk to you for the next 12 hours and wouldn’t begin to tell you all the things that I have done and/or acquired over the past 45+ years. Just the things that I have lost would boggle your mind. But that’s why they say divorces are like hurricanes. Clickety eer: http://www.freepatentsonline.com/3449735.html

    Posted By: MU4WVU2 (8:10am 11-14-2009)
    Report Abuse


    4, a couple questions about your statments seem to be in order.

    "67% of companies do not pay fed tax." Are you speaking of income tax only or all tax, like FICA match? If that is so, why are they exempt? Fed income tax is charged on net income (profit)and not gross income.

    "No Child Left Behind has dumbed us down." How so? The testing required by NCLB has pointed out the deficiencies in education. That was one purpose of the act to define shortcomings in education. NCLB also required the teachers be "highly qualified". Highly qualified means to have an education in the subject area the teacher is teaching. Attempting to remove math or science being taught by someone with a degree in another subject such as phy ed. Most teachers are required to "keep up" via renewal requirements or advanced degrees in subject area.
    If education teaches 3Rs plus computer technology, the students will be able to survive. They will sort themselves out as to the level of success attained.

    Posted By: 4GOD (6:11am 11-14-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Our current economic model is the prime example. “No child left behind” has dumbed us down. We have a few bright students that come through, but there is no middle. The middle was not focused on to expand their potential. We need the middle. We need many, not a few. We greatly lag in international comparison. We lag based off of our own internal needs. Just as economically, our middle class is dwindling to nothing. Can’t have multitudes working for Walmart and McDonalds, a few in the middle and a few in the upper. Ain’t got no one to spend enough money to drive the economy.

    We must acquire knowledge through our entire lives. AS the base of knowledge grows exponentially, we become antiquated and left behind without keeping up.

    If you are going to guide or teach, without keeping up, society would just as soon you not. The students will then be required to pick up, on their own, where your knowledge base acquisition stopped. Very time consuming and costly for business.

    Posted By: 4GOD (6:02am 11-14-2009)
    Report Abuse


    I did read your reply; that is why I put the “don’t invest in telegraphs” comment in. Education is a good thing, but is dependent on the educator. Go look at many of the high school math and science teachers. They are attempting to educate students in areas that they themselves have no background. Not only do they lack background, they lack the basic building blocks required to acquire knowledge (and many times the desire).
    We now find ourselves in a situation called generation bypass. Some students acquire computer and technical skills that surpass the teachers before they reach grade school (they have desire). The worst part is they also go to the internet for their social, moral, ethical and other critical soft skills. So who is teaching them? So we put computers in all of the schools to allow like access to all, yet we do not teach the teachers how to use or apply any of this.

    You have background, you have the ability to acquire; you just refuse to.

    Posted By: SamCogar (2:46am 11-14-2009)
    Report Abuse


    SamCogar, I can't comprehend why you just don't get the "wages should vary with the profits of a company"

    CAPTAINJOE, I would explain that to you but my post would only get DELETED so I see no point in doing so.

    Posted By: SamCogar (2:40am 11-14-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Sam, at least you didn’t call me a serpent. Are you always this hostile when simple facts are pointed out to you? How do you ever expect to grow?

    4GOD, did you get a chance to read my reply to your above question before the PC Police deleted it? I guess I really should quit mentioning the fact that I have a Degree even when posters accuse me of being uneducated.

    Has Dan Rad come back to work for the CN?

    Posted By: rwc (1:29pm 11-13-2009)
    Report Abuse


    justonevoice,many articles have been writen on toyota's pay rate to gm,ford and chrysler.on average,gm had to increase their pay to match toyota's.so who wins?i say the workers won outright when they have better benefits,pay all without a union.so where is the advantage to unionizing?so far,nowhere.

    Posted By: justonevoice (11:25am 11-13-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Without Unions, all of you non-union folks would be working for a dollar and hour.

    Posted By: CAPTAINJOE (8:33am 11-13-2009)
    Report Abuse


    SamCogar,
    I can't comprehend why you just don't get the "wages should vary with the profits of a company" so, I looked at Eastman kodak and confirmed they only vary wage dividends. In the example I gave, your entire wage/hourly rate would vary, not just the dividends.
    Kodak corporation pays a "Wage Dividend," in which each employee benefits 'ABOVE HIS OR HER WAGES' in proportion to the yearly dividend on the company stock. The Wage Dividend was an innovation, and represented a large part of the distribution of the company's net earnings.
    How do you, ever expect to grow,if you don't understand the basic concept of what is said before you comment/attack it?

    Posted By: 4GOD (6:54am 11-13-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Yes, people are leaving the state. Yes, the number of state employees has increased. The service level has definitely not increased.

    We get more Federal subsides than any other state. We got more stimulus money.

    Less people, more support; this defies logic.

    Alt: over 67% of companies do not pay Federal Tax. State tax rates were lowered this year, most companies are located outside the state and are sheltered there. Yet you contend inefficiencies and taxes and wastefulness have forced job loss? The companies did not pay enough taxes in WV to cover their infrastructure and public impact costs. Where is your logic in this?

    Government mandates. Some bad, some good and some are required to protect others (businesses and citizens).

    Yes I am partisan. The neo-con philosophy is in no way related to the Republican Charter. They are Republican In Name only (RINO’s). They lacked the intelligence of a rock. A dumb rock at that.

    Don't invest in telegraphs.

    Posted By: 4GOD (6:50am 11-13-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Pensions and profit sharing for all corporations in 2006 totaled 151 billion. This does not even cover the retirement costs; at the end of 2008 Guaranty had an 11 billion dollar deficit (started in 2002, another previous administration boondoggle). The total corporate net for 2006 was 2 trillion, resulting in 13.25% of net profits distributed in pensions and profit sharing. This is like “one for you, seven for me”. At the same time corporate officers earned 474 billion in compensation, over three times the amount of profit sharing AND pensions. Then they get part of the 151 billion. Of course the officers got more than Uncle Sam. The total income tax paid (before credits) was 453 billion.

    In your example to Captain you state 30% of gross on a $10 million the workers would get $3. The overall representation (for 2006) would be $27 trillion in gross and $151 billion in pensions and profit sharing. The relative percentage, in application, is 0.0056%; and this includes pensions.

    Posted By: SamCogar (3:50am 11-13-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Efficiencies have eliminated 90% of the jobs over the last 50 years. Globalization has moved a large part of the remaining jobs overseas. …… NEWS FLASH: trickle down, demand economics and most of the economic theory you promote fell to the wayside in the 1970’s. Through the ignorance of the previous administration we have proven this once again.

    Your last sentence tells me that you are afflicted with “tunnel vision” and thus are only looking at things through your Partisan Rose Colored Glasses.

    Government inefficiencies, mandates, taxation and wastefulness have eliminated the majority of “lost jobs” over the past 50 years.

    WV population 1950 - 2,005,053, …. 2008 - 1,814,468 with 66,075 State employees.
    Imagine two people packing up and leaving the state almost every hour of every day, and that would best describe West Virginia's migration over the years. http://www.wvdhhr.org/bph/oehp/hsc/briefs/eight/default.htm

    Posted By: SamCogar (2:58am 11-13-2009)
    Report Abuse


    You also pointed out Bower. Nice place, nice people, no opportunity. You would contend that they should start their own businesses.

    4GOD, was nice place, was nice people, was plenty of opportunities. But no more. Bower is no more than a name on a few maps. No people, no houses, no Town. Just a few old foundations overgrown by the brush and trees. And several miles of coal mines that are now filled up with water.

    Posted By: 4GOD (10:18pm 11-12-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Sam, at least you didn’t call me a serpent. Are you always this hostile when simple facts are pointed out to you? How do you ever expect to grow?

    Simple fact unions would not exist if it had not been for the actions of businesses. If you are looking for the root cause start there, otherwise we would all be paid in script and shopping at the company store (as OC pointed out). I will point out that I don’t like unions either, but I do believe in balance and looking at the entire problem; not just selected subsets.

    Toyota: quit interfering with the employees. This will only promote the opposite desires. Let them get it out of their system and it will blow over.

    Toyota employees: you got it pretty good; better think about this one very hard.

    Posted By: 4GOD (10:18pm 11-12-2009)
    Report Abuse


    You also pointed out Bower. Nice place, nice people, no opportunity. You would contend that they should start their own businesses. Who would they sell to? Efficiencies have eliminated 90% of the jobs over the last 50 years. Globalization has moved a large part of the remaining jobs overseas. There is no one working to buy anything. Productivity goes up along with unemployment. The masses are your market; the upper percentage only consumes for only a few. You want them to succeed, without an avenue of success. Then you arbor and promote the very logic that placed them in this position. How can you ever fix anything? Again, a balance thing.

    Posted By: 4GOD (10:16pm 11-12-2009)
    Report Abuse


    NEWS FLASH: trickle down, demand economics and most of the economic theory you promote fell to the wayside in the 1970’s. They barely work in a closed models (and not sustaining), but we definitely do not have a contained economy. Through the ignorance of the previous administration we have proven this once again. Most of the micro or macro economists could not even understand the variables that go into the model; well less describe, create, execute or analyze the results. They lack the mathematic, probability, statistical and logician skills to understand the theory; well less technically create a limited variant model, projecting a single path. How would they ever understand a multi-dimensional model mapping the many actions and reactions that have impact?

    I will say the previous administration did what they had planned. Maximize profit. They just never thought about the other side of the equation; who is left to buy. Limited intellect.

    Posted By: opinionsmatter (6:03pm 11-12-2009)
    Report Abuse


    I have worked at TMMWV as a temporary worker, as well as my husband has been employed by them for almost 11 years.First off to discuss what this is all about. Toyota says that you can talk about the union all you want during your break times you just can not hand out literature. All you Toyota workers that are complaining why don't you go and find a new job that will give you the same pay and benifits you get now, let's see cause you can't find that here in WV. All of you that work at Toyota and have for several years you know that you have went up in pay about $11 since you have started lets see for my hubby that makes it about $1 a year at most places of employment you usually only get a dime or a quarter here and there. I think the union would be the end of your job security, and on top of that you would be paying union dues what a way to loose some more money. Everyone needs to think long and hard before they choose.Remember your family and what you cant get when your on strike.

    Posted By: hoggslopp (12:06am 11-12-2009)
    Report Abuse


    I have been a union man my whole life. I have worked at two jobs where we established new locals. I worked at the stamping plant for almost 15 years and was very active in establishing the union there. At 1st the UAW seemed like a good thing but the deeper we got into I realized dealing with the union was like dealing with the company each had their favorites. I am not saying it was a bad thing, Im just saying it wasnt the answers to all our problems and anyone that tells you that a union is the answer to ALL ur problems is full of crap.

    Do I think the union was the reason the stamping plant shut down,..NO a company is going to do what it can do for its own interest. I dont know how many times at the plant I would go to my reps with problems I was having with management and nothing would be done. It got so bad that I stopped going. I was once told by our local President "I got a stack of problems 3 ft high and ur at the bottom of that stack."

    So my advice is tread carefully

    Posted By: AaronS (9:43am 11-12-2009)
    Report Abuse


    It would require EVERYONE in the company to be on board.

    No, just a majority, same as getting union representation, at least in WV as those who are opposed to unionization are still forced to submit to union demands and dues if the majority votes one in.

    And as far as trust goes, it’s not needed. The information is already out there. Getting compliance from the company side is nothing more then a matter of tweaking information that is already in place as all publically traded corporations have to adhere to SOX requirements and SEC standards among other government requirements.

    The hard part is getting labor to agree to it and that ain't going to happen. The total lack of comment by on here proves it. UAW1002 spent days running his yapper about how a union was needed but he wouldn’t touch this subject with a 100 foot pole. No one from labor will.

    Posted By: CAPTAINJOE (9:30am 11-12-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Aaron, It would require EVERYONE in the company to be on board. Detailed contracts for every position as well as staffing requirements/limitations that spells out what one could expect, along with open books and trust. Emphasis on the word trust.
    It not only could be done, but should be done as everyone wins.
    Health care would have to be addressed as they are not on board with anyone but themselves. Would problably be best to have individual insurance and let competition do its work to keep the costs down. But that brings up another topic, legacy costs? Another company crippler.
    The gov is going to have to get involved in Health care regardless of what we do as its totally out of control now.

    Posted By: AaronS (9:05am 11-12-2009)
    Report Abuse


    "wages should vary with the profits of a company". It sounded practicle, but I don't know of any that practice it.

    I threw out a challenge a couple of days ago to union supporters of putting production standards into union contracts and basing wages on the companies profit, including wage reductions and nary a peep was heard. That's why unions are failing now. Workers don't want a stake in the company, they want annual raises simply because they show up when they want to show up.

    They certainly don't want a union that requires them to work through attendance policies that will terminate them over habitual absenteeism or tardiness with set standards of production and work to be done to receive their pay.

    Posted By: CAPTAINJOE (8:18am 11-12-2009)
    Report Abuse


    "But, for the ones that want to stay, what are they to do?"
    Why not start up their own business and pay themselves Union wages and benefits?
    Excellent! People empowering themselves. One should never be entirely dependant on another. In other words don't place all your eggs in one basket. Another would be go back to college, or a trade school. Get into something that pays what you expect to make.
    If money is your primary focus and you do not have your own business you should consider moving, as, there are a lot more oppertunities in other states. Hence the loss of our sons and daughters and brain drain in this state (promise scholarship recipients)

    Posted By: CAPTAINJOE (8:03am 11-12-2009)
    Report Abuse


    So, If it they make $90 million the third year, they would get a pay cut of $3 million, or $27 million in wages and compensation.
    This would only work if there was verifyible trust, thru an open book policy and the percentage of wages for a position were spelled out in detail. Even then it probably would not work here as workers are not accustom to CUTS in wages and compensation. They would in fact start talking union. And thats where we are today.

    Posted By: CAPTAINJOE (7:46am 11-12-2009)
    Report Abuse


    SamCogar, Your right "Ignorance is not a good excuse."
    “Like my old economics professor use to say, "wages should vary with the profits of a company". It sounded practicle, but I don't know of any that practice it.”

    Key word in the above quote is VARY. If the company makes $10 million this year on average and they are dedicating 30% of Gross to wages and other compensation, the workers would get $3 million in wages and compensation to divide between them. If it make $100 million next year they would get $30 million in wages and compensation.
    This is meant to give workers a stake in the company and a reason to see that it succeeds. Employees owning company stock promotes this as well, although nothing will get your attention faster than a reduction in your paycheck.

    Again, It sounds practicle, but I don't know of any that practice it.

    Posted By: SamCogar (6:28am 11-12-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Like my old economics professor use to say, "wages should vary with the profits of a company". It sounded practicle, but I don't know of any that practice it.

    Ignorance is not a good excuse.

    Kodak Corporation, Hobart Welding, dozens of Stock Brokerages and tens of thousands of corporations and small businesses pay their employees salaries plus Commissions and/or yearly Bonuses with the profits earned by the corporation.

    Posted By: SamCogar (6:12am 11-12-2009)
    Report Abuse


    SamCogar, in 1933, Bower mined a measly 12743 tones of coal. And that was ALL

    Teddy OC, all for 1933, and like most everything else, I wouldn’t expect you to know much more than that.

    The Town of Bower was named for W.H. Bower, assistant general manager for Henry Gassaway Davis, who built the C&C RR from the new Town of Gassaway, past the new Town of Bower and on to the old Town of Burnsville specifically because of the huge coal deposits on Copen Run,

    Bower had become a major shipping point for coal on the C&C. In the fiscal year ending June 30, 1907, Bower had produced 12,180 tons of coal, the first to be reported. For the 1914 fiscal year, this had risen to 143,927 tons, …” West Virginia’s Coal and Coke Railroad – Alan Clarke author

    Posted By: SamCogar (4:08am 11-12-2009)
    Report Abuse


    (4GOD), “And if Bower offered anything other than short term natural resource extraction, it would still be booming. The same example can be noted for hundreds of small towns in WV. Many not related to extraction industries.

    Forgive him Lord for he not knoweth anything about that which he speakith of.

    The perpetuation of blatant ignorance through the populace only exacerbates the trials and tribulations of the ignorant.

    Posted By: SamCogar (3:53am 11-12-2009)
    Report Abuse


    "But, for the ones that want to stay, what are they to do?"

    Why not start up their own business and pay themselves Union wages and benefits?

    Posted By: rwc (9:46pm 11-11-2009)
    Report Abuse


    one citizen you can keep reposting your nonsense,but when you post something that is true and fact based ,instead of outrageous bull,let us know.you may be able to decieve people that don't follow up on your posts,but you cannot decieve people that can disprove you comments.

    Posted By: CAPTAINJOE (9:07pm 11-11-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Like my old economics professor use to say, "wages should vary with the profits of a company". It sounded practicle, but I don't know of any that practice it.
    Times are hard. AEPs talking about raising it's rates, we're in a recession and Health care is like a shark in a fish tank that has been chummed, and, "WE are the fish".
    Perhaps after the recession, when things normalize, would be a better time to start asking for more benefits.
    Hey, it's just a thought.

    Posted By: One Citizen (7:54pm 11-11-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Japan was once a cheap labor country, but today it stands virtually at the top of the world wage table with wage rates between 10 and 30 percent higher than in the US.

    BTW in Japan, Toyota has a strong autoworker's union.
    http://tinyurl.com/yfd3boh

    Those who believe that unions are the downfall of manufacturing here in the US have it completely wrong. It was the gutting of US trade policies by self-serving politicians which killed off a once strong and thriving middle class driven economy. Our founding fathers established trade barriers knowing that they're vital for protecting our economy and our production

    Before Reaganomics there were only about 1 million illegal aliens in our work force, but when he left office 3 million. Today there are over 12 million. Before Reagan the enforcement of laws against hiring illegals served as the barrier to their entry. During that same period union membership dropped from 25% to 7%

    Bottom line? Cheap labor increases corporate profits

    Posted By: One Citizen (7:52pm 11-11-2009)
    Report Abuse


    SamCogar, in 1933, Bower mined a measly 12743 tones of coal. And that was ALL

    http://tinyurl.com/yakr7zy

    It so happens that the Copen Gas Coal Company ran a company store in Bower http://tinyurl.com/yb8eeme

    When the mines unionized, the company store normally shut down because union miners demanded to get paid in real money.

    http://tinyurl.com/yefsa97

    So Bower may have once been a thriving community, pal, but it never thrived until scrip was outlawed. Mining shut down in Braxton because the coke it was processed into was no longer needed to produce steel. Unionization had nothing to do with it whatsoever.

    And yes, Vanwith is near Bower, but look at the timeline of its coal production, and then compare it to the timeline of unionization. The fact is that the UMWA struggled through the 1920s and was practically defunct right up until 1933 when Roosevelt's New Deal kicked in and the National Industrial Recovery Act was passed in 1933.

    Posted By: rwc (7:13pm 11-11-2009)
    Report Abuse


    · www.corpwatch.org/article.php?id=15182 try that on for size,you claim the japanese make 10 to 30 percent higher wages?the wages that toyota pays their workers compared to what gm pays to uaw workers are about the same,more if you include the union dues that and higher benefit apyments that gm workers have to pay.do your research before you make false claims.

    Posted By: rwc (6:59pm 11-11-2009)
    Report Abuse


    btw one citizen,one your link to your comments,try figuring out what their raise would be. not much if you ask me for 6 years of no pay increase.

    Posted By: rwc (6:51pm 11-11-2009)
    Report Abuse


    one citizen,again you post this,but your link gives you no backup to what you imply on your own.wage rates between 10 to 30 percent higher?where does your link provide that information?in japan,the unions are totally different that what is here.they actually stand up for their workers.have you ever been over there to see how these people work?i doubt that you even know a true japanese person.when was the last time a union stood up for their workers.i count three times that my dad and brother worked union jobs,and neither come out with anything,other than lost union dues.my brother can't even get his union rep to call him back.those illegals that you complain about,they work the jobs that many americans shun as if they were better than that.

    Posted By: One Citizen (5:51pm 11-11-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Japan was once a cheap labor country, but today it stands virtually at the top of the world wage table with wage rates between 10 and 30 percent higher than in the US.

    BTW in Japan, Toyota has a strong autoworker's union.
    http://tinyurl.com/yfd3boh

    Those who believe that unions are the downfall of manufacturing here in the US have it completely wrong. It was the gutting of US trade policies by self-serving politicians which killed off a once strong and thriving middle class driven economy. Our founding fathers established trade barriers knowing that they're vital for protecting our economy and our production

    Before Reaganomics there were only about 1 million illegal aliens in our work force, but when he left office 3 million. Today there are over 12 million. Before Reagan the enforcement of laws against hiring illegals served as the barrier to their entry. During that same period union membership dropped from 25% to 7%

    Bottom line? Cheap labor increases corporate profits

    Posted By: ByrdWatcher (4:55pm 11-11-2009)
    Report Abuse


    I really don't care one way or the other, as this plant has no bearing whatsoever on my financial status or my neighborhood though I do now reside in Putnam County. I'm just making a prediction. Toyota will pull out. I give them less than a decade once this starts. Just a prediction. Hope I'm wrong.

    Posted By: AaronS (4:53pm 11-11-2009)
    Report Abuse


    But you can't say unionization is the answer as every major industry that's been in West Virginia went the union route and where are they now? “There’s a reason for the anti-unionization attitude our fellow West Virginians.”

    Posted By: CAPTAINJOE (3:56pm 11-11-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Perhaps get away with it is the wrong words.
    Perhaps, when a new company comes to WV they already know they can pay, oh say $8 an hour and have plenty of people jumping at the opportunity for employment. They can do this with little or no fear that the employees would unionize later, because of the anti-unionization attitude our fellow West Virginians have.
    It's much easier for the people to leave the state to get a better job than it is to stay and expect to get good pay. But, for the ones that want to stay, what are they to do?

    Posted By: AaronS (2:00pm 11-11-2009)
    Report Abuse


    How do employers know they can get away with it? Every major industry that has been in this state has been at one point or another unionized. With that being the case, you can't say if more compaines were union wages would be higher.

    Posted By: CAPTAINJOE (1:57pm 11-11-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Aarons, you have depressed wages because the employers know they can get away with it. WV has some of the lowest electricity rates and property taxes in the nation so one would think this act like a magnet to attract manufacturing companies. The high taxes on fuel and personal property make up for what is lost on property taxes.

    Posted By: CAPTAINJOE (1:47pm 11-11-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Byrdwatcher, I ask the question before "Perhaps some of our commenters that work at the plant could enlighten the rest of us on just what things the TMMWV workers have lost since they have gotten back to work from the layoffs? The benefit cuts along with the companies proclaimed direction to reduce labor costs by $300 million by 2011, is what is fueling talks of forming a Union. There certainly wasn't any before."
    No one has seen fit to answer, Unless of course UAW1002 is stating the following as facts "*these are the times when you need to remember the coworker that was injured at work and was terminated or how you've been on an off shift and a temp has been on the more desired shift or how production has increased in numbers but the amount of employees hasnt.
    * think of who made the decisions to take away that bonus, raise premiums on your insurance...did you have a voice in any of those decisions? NO! ", which I believe he is, having heard the same thing from a neighbor.

    Posted By: ByrdWatcher (1:26pm 11-11-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Well, there goes Toyota. We can't seem to keep from doing it to ourselves. I remember all of the bragging and gloating and prestige that everyone felt when first going to work at the Buffalo plant. Now everyone is tired of working so much. Let's organize a Union! Then the plant will leave (like everyone else) and we won't have to worry about it anymore. Geez. I know a ton of people who would love the opportunity to work there just the way it's run now. Great.

    Posted By: AaronS (10:25am 11-11-2009)
    Report Abuse


    It's not only the IT job Captian. West Virginia pays depressed wages in many occupations save mining. Considering we were at one time a union state, we know union's is not the answer.

    Posted By: CAPTAINJOE (7:55am 11-11-2009)
    Report Abuse


    SamCougar, Accepted the 10k and benefits cut because my wife wanted to move back home with her dying mother. Do not regret what I did, but, was just trying to point out the difference between having union representation and not having it. Also got tired of people slamming unions by regurgeitating things they have heaard.
    SamCougar, 4GOD, When the natural resources, The tax cuts, and cheap labor and CHEAP ELECTRIC POWER (AEP), runs out the company leaves, period.
    Century Aluminum - they can pack up and leave right now as far as I'm concerned. They want AEP to give them cheaper rates and raise the power rates on peolple in Jackson county, while they destroy the union and pay as little as possible to their workers. Hasta la vista baby!

    Posted By: 4GOD (4:59am 11-11-2009)
    Report Abuse


    And if Bower offered anything other than short term natural resource extraction, it would still be booming. The same example can be noted for hundreds of small towns in WV. Many not related to extraction industries.

    Simple logic. If the resources were currently there for extraction, why are they not being mined? Do you think a company would pay taxes on unutilized mineral rights? I guess the county could have given them such a cut in property taxes that waiting did not impact the bottom line.

    Alternately , it takes less than 4% of the miners now to extract the same amount of coal. Remove 96 out of a hundred people and what do you have.

    Manufacturing variables operate differently, just noting the comparison is invalid.

    Posted By: SamCogar (3:51am 11-11-2009)
    Report Abuse


    The Town of Bower was by far the largest Town in Braxton County with hundreds of residents and a vibrant economy that attracted shoppers and visitors from Gilmer, Lewis and other Towns in Braxton County.

    Then the “deprived” coal miners moved in from Clay County and organized a Union.

    The Town of Bower is now but a memory and a couple old building foundations that one can still see iffen you know where to look for them.

    Posted By: SamCogar (3:26am 11-11-2009)
    Report Abuse


    The major difference I personally experienced when moving to WV as an IT professional was a $10k cut in pay and having to loose my fully paid health and vision care.

    There has to be a story behind that. Was it the “cost-of-living” differential that prompted your move to WV and now you have THOUSAND$ more in cash in your pocket at the end of the year?

    Oh, by the way, at my WV office of technology "non-union" job, the guy in the cubicle next to me slept in his office chair for days on end and nothing was ever done about it.

    HA, do you think you told us something we didn’t already know?

    Posted By: rwc (11:45pm 11-10-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Toyota came to WV because our depressed economy gave them plenty of cheap labor, your link says nothing to what you claim,one citizen,and you are making assumptions that have no basis.what one corporation does,does not talk for all companies.toyota did not have to build here in this state and if they organize a union,that would be a slap in the face to the very people that brought them here.

    Posted By: One Citizen (10:55pm 11-10-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Toyota came to WV because our depressed economy gave them plenty of cheap labor, and with it they could push back against the rapidly expanding unions in Japan
    http://tinyurl.com/yfd3boh

    General Electric CEO Jack Welch publicly admitted that corporations naturally push for laws that permit them to "have every plant on a barge", and allow them to easily go to the country with the worst conditions to exploit

    I'd just like to know who drafted that GOP health care bill amendment set up to provide US backed "sweatshop insurance" to the Marianas Islands. http://tinyurl.com/yls77lv

    Those who push "free trade" over U.S. trade protections are supporting the corporate push for exploitable labor through globalization. The industry insider publication at http://insidetrade.com/ recently revealed that transnational corporations are planning to lobby against new trade regs designed to curtail the import of all goods made with convict labor, forced and indentured child labor

    Posted By: yogipsk (10:12pm 11-10-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Only unionization will get you laid off like everyone at GM/Chrysler and Ford, see what the UAW has done for them...nothing. You have a good job with a good salary keep it or join the union and see how fast Toyota finds somewhere to move their plant...

    Posted By: WVHillbilly (9:03pm 11-10-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Bravo for them! Only unionization will preserve the middle class. . . at least what's left of it.

    Posted By: rwc (8:16pm 11-10-2009)
    Report Abuse


    one citizen,before you speak on japanese unions check them out.they are nothing like the uaw or any union in the usa.they actually do their job,unlike the unions here that lie and steal their way into people's pockets.every been to japan?try it sometime,one citizen.

    Posted By: CAPTAINJOE (8:11pm 11-10-2009)
    Report Abuse


    I worked in unions off and on over the years and overall have come away with a good feeling about them. You keep hearing about unions that protect the lazy workers but that has not been my experience. If you have a competent manager that documents, follows up and punishes unwanted behavior, the unions are rendered powerless. The major difference I personally experienced when moving to WV as an IT professional was a $10k cut in pay and having to loose my fully paid health and vision care. If your looking for a savior, go to church. A Union can only help with negotiations as there is strength in numbers and in unwarrented firings or retributions.
    Oh, by the way, at my WV office of technology "non-union" job, the guy in the cubicle next to me slept in his office chair for days on end and nothing was ever done about it. This was clearly the managers fault.

    Posted By: MountaineerForLife (4:13pm 11-10-2009)
    Report Abuse


    You might as well quit while you're ahead. People like uaw1002 and One Citizen don't realize what they're getting themselves into. Let them make the mistake for themselves. Let them get the union started for a few people at the Toyota Plant and end up causing everyone to lose their job. Let them live with that. Let them be the ones to put their families at risk, just for their perceived "right" to be payed $80 and hour and leave the production line whenever they want.

    You want to bear that responsibility? You want to cost over a thousand jobs just for the sake of a few people who feel so "entitled" that they will stop at nothing short of getting every single person laid off to see that accomplished.

    Go ahead, be my guest.

    Posted By: AaronS (3:27pm 11-10-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Our founding fathers established trade barriers because they are vital for protecting our economy and our production.

    That's a hoot. About the only politician today who has a like minded trade policy of our founding fathers as they advocated a non-interventionist foreign policy coupled with a free trade policy with any and all would be Ron Paul and his Libertarian political views.

    Trade barriers of our founding fathers. I needed a good laugh today.

    Thanks.

    Posted By: BigJP7997 (3:27pm 11-10-2009)
    Report Abuse


    I have grown up in a family of very strong Union supporters. I have been the member of different Unions at different times. From the outside looking in though I have seen that they are not effective or needed anymore. These workers will cause Toyota to leave the state if they don't keep their mouths shut. I know people who work there and from what I know they have it good.

    Posted By: One Citizen (1:38pm 11-10-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Those who believe that unions are the downfall of manufacturing here in the US have it completely wrong. It was the gutting of U.S. trade policies by self-serving politicians that killed off a once strong and thriving middle class driven economy. Our founding fathers established trade barriers because they are vital for protecting our economy and our production.

    Before Reagan there were only about 1 million illegal aliens in our work force, but when he left office 3 million. Today there are over 12 million. Before Reagan the enforcement of laws against hiring illegals served as the barrier to their entry. During that same period union membership dropped from 25% to 7%.

    Bottom line? Cheap labor increases corporate profits.

    Japan was once a cheap labor country, but today it stands virtually at the top of the world wage table with wage rates between 10 and 30 percent higher than in the US.

    BTW in Japan, Toyota has a strong autoworker's union.

    http://tinyurl.com/yfd3boh

    Posted By: Julius88 (10:00am 11-10-2009)
    Report Abuse


    You have to want to go back on to welfare to vote a union in. You will be sorry.

    Posted By: slaton (7:11am 11-10-2009)
    Report Abuse


    UAW 1002, You say Toyota has violated your right to discuss/pass out literature in our group houses because it is deemed a work area. I work there and I don't feel that my rights have been infringed upon. We who are for a union-free workplace have rights as well. We have the right not to be subjected to your discussions and hand-outs in our group houses. There are other places for you to take your 10 minute 'breaks' such as the 'smoke shack', where I'm sure most of you go anyway. Pass out your literature in the parking lot or at the entrances, if you must. I guess the real issue is getting your message to people you don't normally see in the smoke shack or the parking lot--not of your rights.

    Posted By: rwc (10:54pm 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    uaw1002,if you work there,feel lucky to be holding down a job.if feel it's right to unionize the place,then also respect the japanese when they decide to close up shop and move elsewhere.personally,i think your going to shoot yourselves in the foot with this.when you do,you can only thank yourself when you stand in line at wv workforce.

    Posted By: AaronS (7:34pm 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    That's one side of the story uaw1002.

    Posted By: uaw1002 (6:37pm 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    "Toyota has set up our 'break areas' to be so-called 'work areas.'

    "By doing so they are interfering with our rights under the National Labor Relations Act to pass out literature. We are standing up for our legal rights and have asked the United Auto Workers for resources to help us address this issue."

    workers rights have been violated.

    Posted By: rwc (6:05pm 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    uaw1002 ,why don't you just ask them shut the doors on this plant.the union has not stood behind their people in years. all they're in it for is the money.

    Posted By: sgb (5:53pm 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    I Really, Really hope the engine plant unionizes, I can't wait for Toyota to move all those jobs to South Carolina.

    Posted By: MountaineerForLife (5:11pm 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    You want the Union, fine. There are some exceptions where Unions can be good for workers - but anymore, it's VERY few. ESPECIALLY the UAW. They may have not been the only reason GM failed - but they were a BIG reason.

    I agree with sox, and efillc. And UAW1002 - Educate ourselves? Yeah, by reading Union propaganda? I was a former Union man, until I was busting my rear for absolutely nothing. I read that propaganda, and fell for it. And I won't make that mistake again. The SEIU ripped off my wife for more than $2,000 at the time she worked at a nursing home. And did nothing for the workers. Unions are no longer about workers, it's about the dues.

    Toyota, don't be fooled by the Union propagandists. You will make a serious mistake.

    GOODBYE TOYOTA!

    Posted By: AaronS (4:47pm 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    to remember the coworker that was injured at work and was terminate

    I'm going to have to call a big Bull Shinola on that one.

    Posted By: sox (4:27pm 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Don't get me wrong not my buisness if you want the Union. By all means do what is best for you. Just remember this ain't your daddy's union.

    Posted By: sox (4:24pm 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    The cost of playing at your 33 million dollar resort

    18 holes with cart $55 $65 $75 $85
    9 holes with cart $35 $40 $45 $55
    Twilight with cart $45 $55 $60 $65
    But hey since they used your money to buy it you get 20% off. How nice of them....

    Posted By: sox (4:20pm 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Posted by UAW1002

    the UAW will not come in your plant, sign your cards, nor will they negotiate your contract.

    I agree the Unions of today will not do anything for the working man. They are in it for the money. If your UAW had on once of backbone the entire UAW would walk out in your Cal. Toyota plant until this got solved. will they? NOPE.... You see it right here Buffalo plant you are on your own... Give us your money and we will ignore you.. If you need us look us up.


    If the Unions operated like they did back when they started it would be different but this is the face of Unions today. A 33 million dollar golf resort. Bring back the days of Hoffa and Grandma Moses then I'll join your Union.

    http://www.blacklakegolf.com/

    Posted By: uaw1002 (4:18pm 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    TOYOTA WORKERS, stand strong! these are your rights! Toyota will try several tactics, such as offering a BONUS, or imply the UAW/union is a 3 rd party (which is NOT true). they may even start having more team member meetings, maybe hold luncheons to try to show you how you all are one big family.
    *these are the times when you need to remember the coworker that was injured at work and was terminated or how you've been on an off shift and a temp has been on the more desired shift or how production has increased in numbers but the amount of employees hasnt.
    * think of who made the decisions to take away that bonus, raise premiums on your insurance...did you have a voice in any of those decisions? NO!
    be smart! take care of each other, STAND STRONG.

    Posted By: sox (4:08pm 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    CO the Chevette... Are you kidding me that was a great product turned out by GM... They still have those things on the road.. The Chevette and the Escort are two of the best ideas ever. I do agree with the part about being stupid (retarded is a nasty word) before looking at the facts. Like these.

    According to JD powers the most dependable cars for the last three years (2006 models) they place first in Subcompact, compact, midsize sport ,Full size Lux ,and Lux sport. They finish second in Compact and midsize (your Camry) not bad for a lapse in quality I'd say.

    http://www.cars.com/go/advice/Story.jsp?section=buy&story=topDependCar&subject=most_depend&referer=&aff=national


    While Unions are not the only problem. I fail to feel sorry for the guys who made $40 an hour for twenty years and now the well is dry.

    As for these guys it is up to them Vote Union or not. They know what could happen, just don't ask me to boycott Toyota if they leave. If it will help you then vote it in

    Posted By: Mothman (3:54pm 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    The US automakers declined because they became banks and car making was no longer a priority. Unions are democratic organizations that represent workers. Capital in the US has been outsourcing to bust American unions. The US currency (the dollar) is worthless scrip.
    Corporations are conducting economic genocide against the American workers and unions. It saddens me to see so many people buy into corporate propaganda and embrace working against their own interest toward a lower standard of living. If we don't stand up for our rights,
    we'll get more economic slavery.

    Posted By: uaw1002 (3:50pm 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    JPMUGIRL


    American unions are formed the same way! THE WORKERS HAVE TO MAKE A STAND TOGETHER AND THEY ARE THE ONES TO FORM THEIR UNION! the UAW will not come in your plant, sign your cards, nor will they negotiate your contract. the UAW is ONLY a resource for workers. further more i think that there are several UN-educated comments about the UAW/UNION on here. research and educate yourself, don't rely on the media to give you your educated opinion! form the opinion yourself after you have done the research.
    TO THE EMPLOYEES WHO TOOK A STAND FOR THEIR RIGHTS* GOOD FOR YOU! MORE OF US SHOULD STAND UP FOR OUR RIGHTS IN THE WORKPLACE.

    Posted By: Captain Obvious (2:14pm 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    GM and Chrysler didn't fail because of the UAW; they failed due to arrogant management and consistently horrendous product. You can't point at the UAW for the Vega, Skylark, Neon, Chevette (a/k/a "Shove-It), Aztek, Cimarron, and every other rolling turd that came out of Detroit. Ford made some crap too, but at least they're shaping up-- and guess what; they're still union. Unions, by the way, are much stronger in Germany than the US, and so far the only companies in trouble there are VW and Opel, not known for quality of late.

    Point being, whether or not a unionized Toyota plant can remain commercially viable is entirely dependent on the situation at hand. If it is, it is, and if it isn't, it isn't. Waving an ideological banner before looking at the facts is flat-out retarded. Let's remember, Toyota's recent lapses in quality occurred with NO union. Camrys, for example, are built at a non-union plant in Georgetown, KY.

    Posted By: rwc (12:40am 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    vote the uaw in,see you on the unemployment line.i highly doubt the japanese will go for that.

    Posted By: bongo (11:33am 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Well, those jobs were nice while they lasted.

    Posted By: wvpride (11:24am 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    People need to wake up, this has nothing to do with Union or Non Union, this has to do with us excersing our rights in the work place. We have the right to talk about everything else when we are on break but Union stuff thats the issue. Toyota says we need to make an informed decision, how we can we do that if they wont let us talk to our co-workers when we are break. What a joke!! Well here is the deal, we are going to talk with our co-workers and our voices will not be shut down.

    Posted By: labgrunt (11:00am 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    What a joke. Unions have important friends in high places now, i.e. PrezBO.
    Apparently the demise of union-dominated industries in WV (chemicals, coal, labor, etc) has had little or no lasting impact on the myopic vision of union bosses.
    The $35,000 car that these engines go into will soon cost $50,000 or more if a union succeeds in organizing the workers at Toyota. Look at the city of Nitro (and the entire Kanawha Valley for that matter)...a shadow of what it once was since the unions drove Monsanto (Flexsys), FMC (Great Lakes Chemical), and other large employers in the area out of business. I was there...saw it with my own eyes. The organized labor largesse, the entitlements, the never-ending filing of grievances (real or perceived...mostly perceived).
    Yep, Toyota will shut the doors and lock the gate if this unionization movement succeeds. Proof? Look at what's left of the Big 3 and UAW, and the skeleton of Detroit. Ford is surviving, but just barely. Pathetic...

    Posted By: efillc (10:42am 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Dear Toyota Execs: VA, TX, and SC are all right to work states, and nne of them are union-friendly (probably because folks there prefer jobs to unemployment). Just saying...

    Posted By: kittykat (10:33am 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Boy, they don't get it do they? We're in the middle of the worst economic crisis in decades. Anyone with a job needs to be kissing the ground they work on. Now these bozos are going to eff with the Japanese? They will close the place down and I don't blame them.

    Posted By: AaronS (9:12am 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Here's the challenge to pro-union individuals. Are you willing to accept in your contract pre set production quota's and if they are not met, a pay system based on what is actually produced minus a break down?

    Are you willing to accept a very strict attendance policy that terminates habitual employees for tardiness and missed work days?

    Are you willing to accept a pay scale that is closely tied to a profit/loss margin, meaning if the company has a down year, you're willing to take a cut in pay?

    Are you willing to control some of your health care cost by enrolling in high deductible health care plans, paying for preventative health care out of your pocket and shopping around to save on health care cost so the company can reduce its cost?

    Are you willing to drum out poor performing employees instead of saving and fighting the company at every turn?

    If you can say yes to these and similar policies, then I would say yes to a union. If not, adios, hasta leugo.

    Posted By: CAPTAINJOE (8:18am 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Perhaps some of our commenters that work at the plant could enlighten the rest of us on just what things the TMMWV workers have lost since they have gotten back to work from the layoffs? The benefit cuts along with the companies proclaimed direction to reduce labor costs by $300 million by 2011, is what is fueling talks of forming a Union. There certainly wasn't any before.

    Posted By: MountaineerForLife (8:16am 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Are you serious? A union? Do they not pay attention? Do they live under a rock? Toyota is an excellent company to work for WITHOUT A UNION and this is how you repay companies that invest in our communities.

    If you start that Union, good luck finding a job in 5 years. Toyota will be long gone.

    Posted By: WVU1981 (5:50am 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    I hope and pray the workers at Toyota are smart enough not to vote in the union and become like GM, Chrysler).

    Posted By: SamCogar (5:05am 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    I had previously issued a challenge to cite one example of a long term industry in WV that is both profitable and unionized that is not subsidized by the government

    bennysaunders89, the response to your challenge is DEAFENING.

    Posted By: SamCogar (4:56am 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    We build V6 engines at a rate of 1 per 58.9 seconds with 100% accuracy that goes into a $35,000 vehicle which Toyota requires a contract if you want to buy one. All I'm asking is a contract in return for building it.

    YUP, and the School Administrators and Teachers in West Virginia have a Contract that includes Tenure Rights and guaranteed annual pay increases and which negates any fears of being terminated no matter what the QUALITY of the PRODUCT is that they push out the doors onto the public. The very PRODUCT that business and corporate managers must choose from to perform the work that the public requires 100% accuracy when it is PRODUCED. An oxymoronic "requirement".

    So, if you want the same QUALITY of PRODUCT that the Public Schools produce then give all employees in WV the equivalent BOE Contract that school employees have.

    Posted By: slaton (1:54am 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    It has become obvious that all of you pro-union Toyota team members have chosen the Gazette to get the attention you crave. I'm glad you're doing it here instead of in the parking lot like you did before. I vaguely remember Mr. Snyder bragging to people about hitting one of those stamping plant union people with his side mirror. Now he's become one of them. Sad.

    Posted By: WV resident (12:48am 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Look what the union did for the stamping plant in South Charleston... Beware Toyota employees; going union will mean the end of your jobs. If you don't like the policies at your workplace, quit and find employment elsewhere.

    Posted By: libertylover (12:47am 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    I want to pose a question to all the adamantly anti Toyota posters. Where were the components for the computer you are looking at manufactured? Just so you know even the Union Built PC and ZT Systems PC may be assembled in the USA but the majority of components are imported.

    Another thing many seem to fail to realize is no matter what you buy you are benefiting the local economy. When you buy a vehicle the commission made by the salesman gets spent at local restaurants and local retail stores and grocery stores further helping others in our area by supporting the workers at these locations. We may live in a global economy but where you buy is vastly more important to the people posting here than what you buy.

    Posted By: libertylover (12:34am 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    I work in a non union job. I was able to be promoted based on merit, not seniority. My raises are merit based. People who are lazy and continually make mistakes are fired.

    A union would have kept me from my promotion. A union would have the lazy workers get the same raise as me. A union would help save the jobs of the worthless people we get rid of.

    If all workers are smart they will realize unions benefit union bosses, lazy workers, and people who are too stupid to make it on their own merit.

    Posted By: LightningBoy (12:11am 11-09-2009)
    Report Abuse


    AaronS; That is an incorrect statement. We are a very successful plant that is bringing back temp workers (for a projected time frame of anywhere between 3-24 months) that doesn't make near the same wage as a Toyota TM and has zero benefits. As for the weather in Mexico, ask your fellow Toyota TM's in Baja, Mexico that make the 4 door Tacoma. They'll probably tell you it's about the same as the rest of the plants in the South (TMMTX, TMMAL, TMMMS)...wages and weather are pretty similar down there. All these gentlemen in the article are asking for is to be able to discuss the option of a union with the other TM's in their respective break areas. A lot of TM's want to hear what the pro-union employees have to say without resrictions from Toyota management. Our break areas are not "work" areas, plain and simple...Freedom is a beautiful thing, but only if you possess it.

    Posted By: AaronS (10:31pm 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    we are a VERY successful plant that is currently hiring!

    How's the weather in Mexico???

    Posted By: simple person (9:49pm 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Look at the UMWA and what they have done for their membership with the support of Obama. The union supported a candadate who openly advocated the demise of the very industry they represent in bowing to a political party.

    Modern day unions for the most part are political whores.

    Posted By: brakegirl (8:57pm 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    WOW! It's sad to hear people let companies off the hook so easily. Toyota did wrong, plain and simple. The workers who filed against Toyota took the first step, which is educating their selves. Read the FACTS people. A union is as strong as the workers who form the union. Toyota is a very educated and organized company with a plan, why is it so wrong for the workers to be educated and organize a plan for their future?

    For all of you who say just quit and find another job, you do live in the USA, RIGHT? No matter what city/state you live in whether your in a union or not, auto industry or any occupation, people all over are losing their jobs. It is called bad management and competition. If my company is succeeding, than my workers should get paid for helping the company succeed. Why should I get to take a summer vacation because my company has succeeded, but not give my workers a vacation? It’s NOT fair. When you quit over bad management your letting the company win.

    UNION YES!

    Posted By: One Citizen (8:38pm 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    It took a union-backed illegal sit-in to get Big Finance to trickle down the very first of Bush's bailout funds to aid Main Street Americans

    Back in December, the glass workers' union (UE Local 1110 Chicago) sit-in was successful because it focused directly on the hoarding of the billions in bailout cash that Bush had then recently forked over to Big Finance with no strings attached. But nationally, the story of the union's success at getting even a small portion of the bailout money to trickle down to Main Street never got much attention in either the press or on capitol hill.
    UPDATE HERE
    http://tinyurl.com/y9jbxft

    For far too long, disaster capitalists have been able to screw the middle class because of the corporate-owned media's obvious reluctance to report what a raw deal Wall Street gives Main Street

    BTW unions are also one of the too few ways by which working class Americans can even out the overwhelming power that corporate lobbyists hold over those we elect.

    Posted By: tmmk21 (8:27pm 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Good job aaron s...yeah, turns out Biller was a "disgruntled" Toyota employee. Imagine that! I guess you can't believe anything he says now can you?
    Maybe the NHTSA has something to say about the floor mat issue...
    http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20091104/ap_on_bi_ge/us_toyota_floor_mats_3

    Posted By: CAPTAINJOE (8:02pm 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    ok,I'll try this one more time. Respect and Teamwork are two integral parts of a certain culture. Are you sure the management of the North American branch is on board with this concept? Have they strayed or been redirected?

    Posted By: uaw1002 (7:40pm 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    ok ok i have read enough UNTRUE comments about GM,FORD AND CHRYSLER to make me about want to vomit!
    i only have 1 question for you. when you purchased your home/vehicle did you hand shake on the deal with the bank? did you trust the bank would not raise your payments? was the bank crazy enough to loan you any amount of money on a handshake? NOPE! you signed a CONTRACT FOLKS.
    I am a PROUD UAW MEMBER! i have a contract that gives me added protection and a voice at the table. when changes have to be made i get to be involved in those changes. i lose NOTHING unless i , as well as my coworkers, VOTE ON THOSE CHANGES. we are a VERY successful plant that is currently hiring! oh and i forgot to mention we have been organized for over 55yrs!!!!!!! SOLIDARITY FOREVER! UNION YES! standing up for fair treatment and fair wages/benefits WILL NOT BE THE DEATH OF TMMWV! stay strong and be proud! LET YOUR VOICES BE HEARD!

    Posted By: slaton (6:32pm 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    I posted earlier and the state newspaper of WV felt the need to remove it--I guess because I'm anti-union. I only want to say that I've worked for Toyota WV for 10 1/2 years and the workers who were interviewed would benefit from union representation. You may derive whatever meaning you wish from that statement. TMMWV has suffered through an economic downturn and poor American management, but we still have a good place to work and support our families. The day union is chosen for TMMWV will spell the beginning of the end. I hope I haven't offended the state newspaper of WV.

    Posted By: bennysaunders89 (4:02pm 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    I had previously issued a challenge to cite one example of a long term industry in WV that is both profitable and unionized that is not subsidized by the government and pipedreams57 had suggested healthcare. Healthcare is so heavily subsidized by public funds to the point of discussions of nationalizing this industry. Union Labor Uber Allies! Go go big government!
    I encourage someone to please provide this example for me. I am limited in the scope of my research and would genuinely like to know if such a thing exists.

    Posted By: WEST VIRGINIAN (3:42pm 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    The UNION PLANTS in West Virginia have mainly all closed and/or laid off the Union Employees as follows:

    F.M.C.Chemical Plant in South Charleston--USW AFL-CIO
    F.M.C. Ordnance Plant in South Charleston-UAW AFL-CIO
    Volkswagen Plant in South Charleston------UAW AFL-CIO
    Union parts Plant in South Charleston-----UAW AFL-CIO
    Union Carbide in South Charleston---------IAM AFL-CIO
    Aluminum Plants in Ravenswood-------------USW AFL-CIO
    Steel Plants in Weirton-------------------USW AFL-CIO
    etc.....

    The Employees @ Toyota are too intelligent to vote in the UAW AFL-CIO, the UAW has sold out more workers in 2009 then any Industry in History.

    The UAW AFL-CIO is a dying union and the UNION BOSSES are looking for more 'suckers' to send dues to Detroit.

    Posted By: soggybottomboy (1:22pm 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Big mistake folks.......

    Posted By: pacaderm (12:59am 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Since Obama hit town.......I buy Ford when I buy American. I'll buy any foreign car over the state owned GM and Chrysler

    Posted By: LightningBoy (10:42am 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    DJE; Read my comment carefully. Toyota will not close TMMWV based on a vote in favor of the union, but if it can show it does not turn a profit for a specified period of time. How much profit did Howes Tannery make while it still was operating ? I bet it's not even close as to what TMMWV pulls in. It doesn't matter how good of a product they made, if they were not making any money (union or not) the company will shut the door. At least when they ended operations, the workers got something. If TMMWV were to close it's doors today, every single worker in the plant would walk away with nothing. At least when NUMMI closes, the workers are getting some form of a compensation package. Do you work for TMMWV ? World class leather vs World class engines is not a fair comparison. We build V6 engines at a rate of 1 per 58.9 seconds with 100% accuracy that goes into a $35,000 vehicle which Toyota requires a contract if you want to buy one. All I'm asking is a contract in return for building it.

    Posted By: True WV (10:35am 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    @rwc Honda built a plant in Maryville, OH. My brother in law worked for a brake rotor manufacturer in OH. Honda would not even let the OH brake rotor manufacture give them a bid on rotors. They ordered them from Japan. GMHoover is right, buy a American car with the headquarters here and you help America more. Our Democrat and Republican politicans are sending jobs overseas as quickly as they can. Only the American consumer can make the decision to buy American.

    Posted By: AaronS (10:10am 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Toyota has tried to silence Demitrios Biller, a former attorney for Toyota that has decided to tell the truth.

    Something doesn't sound right about this so I googled Biller. Seems he didn't decide to tell the truth until AFTER he was forced out by Toyota. On top of that, he's claiming that Toyota lawyers subjected perjury. Why didn't he come forth when that happnened?

    http://www.aboutlawsuits.com/toyota-floor-mat-recall-could-have-been-issued-earlier-6268/

    In addition to the recall, the company faces serious allegations that officials withheld safety studies and other evidence in Toyota rollover lawsuits in recent years. The allegations come from a former Toyota attorney, Demitrios Biller, who is suing the company for forcing him out.

    Biller’s claims that Toyota hid the results of crashworthiness tests and told engineers to lie on the stand, leading to the re-opening of several product liability lawsuits against Toyota.

    Posted By: CAPTAINJOE (9:59am 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    one of the first things your taught when you form any sort of "TEAM" is that there is no "I's" in the word team. There are three "I's" in Seiichi Sudo, instead of thinking about where you would like to go, think about whats best for toyota in the long run. Don't let profits cloud your judgment when it comes to your teams. They have done a fantastic job and everyone involved needs to be rewarded acordingly, not, just management and stockholders.

    Posted By: DJE (9:54am 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    LightningBoy;ask the former workers at the Howes Tannery in Frank WV about unions.They went on strike and one year later their plant was closed,even tho they made the "best leather in the world", bar none.They thought the union would protect them.They let the worker's be bought out for pennies on the dollar for their retirement deductions.The company walked away with fat wallets and the workers got squat,and the union did nothing.

    Posted By: tmmk21 (9:49am 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    The recent recalls are a symptom of poor management. Using temp workers that are not adequately trained, covering up defects that put public safety at risk, cutting quality in order to maximize profit.
    Say what you want about union labor. You cannot say that any union members are involved in design, vehicle development, engineering, or marketing of any vehicle. If management decides to build something, it is up to the assembly worker to put it together.
    The Toyota workers in Indiana or Texas did their jobs....it's not their fault that some manager decides to cut costs by turning their back on issues that compromise quality or safety.
    It turns out Toyota was aware of some issues like the rollover problem with some vehicles and the so-called floor mat issue now appears to be an engineering issue regarding the accelerator pedal and has nothing to do with the floor mat.
    Toyota has tried to silence Demitrios Biller, a former attorney for Toyota that has decided to tell the truth.

    Posted By: tmmk21 (9:33am 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Toyota is making many of the same mistakes that the Big 3 made in the past.
    Manufacturing vehicles that the public won't buy....Tundra, Sequoia, and Solara. The first two are big gas hogs that are just not fuel efficient and are not worth relying on in terms of devoting an entire plant to their construction. The Solara, just like most coupes are a niche vehicle that has a small sales potential.
    The President of Toyota just apologized for failed quality, the recent recalls and the deaths of the family in California because of the floor mat issue. However, the Toyota plant in KY is hiring people through three different temporary agencies paying wages from $8.50 to $14.50 per hour. Without any benefits provided, the top paying temp jobs offer health care at $70.00 per WEEK and three vacation days per year starting out.
    A new strategy in order to break people down is a two job rotation and discussion of using alternating shifts like the TMMTX plant.
    Toyota, your employer will destroy you

    Posted By: CAPTAINJOE (9:17am 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Seiichi Sudo, president of Toyota in North America, wrote a five-year "Self-Reliance Plan" back in 2006 outlining company plans to reduce labor costs by $300 million by 2011.
    "Our strategy moving forward is to base our hourly wages more closely with the state manufacturing wages where each plant is located, and not tie ourselves so closely to the U.S. auto industry, or other competitors," Sudo wrote.
    That sounds strikingly simular to the Walmart stragety. Go into a place, estabish yourself, raise prices on your products give your workers that built your business nothing. It even goes one step farther, lets reduce the workers wages.....
    I for one wont be buying another Toyota.

    Posted By: AaronS (9:08am 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    You can't pin the failure of the big 3 on the blue collar crowd. Corporate planning put all the eggs in the SuV/Truck basket and when gas prices soared they failed.

    The F-150 remained the number 1 selling vehicle. #2-Chevy Silverado.

    GM failed because they were paying starting wages of $28.00/hour and had legacy cost of over $4000.00 per vehicle. And in contracts years ago, they promised no one would be laid off due to technology so they were paying people to watch machinery work. Additionally, the ones that did get laid off due to low sales were put in job banks that paid 90 to 95% of their working wages so there was no incentive for union workers to make any concessions. Add that to the fact that GM put most of their plants under one contract, thus a secondary parts plant could strike and bottleneck 5 or 6 plants out of work and you have a company doomed for bankruptcy. Toyota will not make the same contract mistakes GM did.

    Posted By: pacaderm (8:22am 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    TOYOTA
    Better take your jobs and leave now. Once these vampires get their teeth in you.......you're done.
    Just look around at the business, welfare and state government climate in West Virginia, all proudly brought to us by the union.

    Posted By: Taxpayer (8:22am 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Everyone thinks union jobs "break the bank". My son works at Rite Aid and is in the union. He is a shift supervisor in a retail store and makes $8 per hour. Most union jobs are just as good for the company in that it gives them fixed costs. Rite Aid actually user their union against them as a club. Contracts cut both ways. Only the Big 3 have historically paid insane wages. I was in a union at a hubcap factory in Spencer WV and was paid 20 cents above minimum wage in 1978. Just food for thought.

    Posted By: jackthepepsiman (8:06am 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Go ahead and get the union in there. Look at what the union has done for the employees of GM/Ford/Chrysler. Look at what the Teamsters union has done for the trucking industry while you're at it. Look at what the unions have done for the chemical plants in South Charleston. Go ahead and shoot yourselves in the foot!

    Posted By: 4GOD (7:26am 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Ohkan3, they do 3 things. They take their hard earned tax dollars. Look up AFL-CIO in the below links. These are just specific programs and do not include the total amount of “grants”. Worst part is AFL-CIO controlled various organizations and SEIU back in 2005. Very bad to have employers and the employee union both controlled by an upper union. These contracts are still in place. They do "not" meet the Recovery Act wage or benefit requirements, but the Service Contract Act does not apply; HHS issues grants. You will have to talk to the HHS Secretary on this one. She is too busy trying to control you health insurance to care about grantee employees. Her department even stated these were arm’s length negotiations. She is to busy to correct any of her departments other legal transgressions.
    http://www.govtrack.us/congress/record.xpd?id=110-s20071114-21
    http://www.fedspending.org/faads/faads.php?&cfda_program_num=93.600&sortby=u&datype=T&reptype=a&database=faads&detail=2

    Posted By: LightningBoy (7:01am 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    I currently work for TMMWV and I encourage each hourly paid employee that works there to at least hear out what the TM's, who are for the union, have to say. There are many Toyota plants globally (i.e. UK, South Africa, Japan, etc..) that are currently union, and TMMC is seriously considering this route as well. TMMWV is not going to close it's doors simply if the workforce votes in favor of the union, that's nonsense. Federal laws prohibit a corporation from doing that, TMMWV has to prove they are losing money over a period of time before they can even consider that option. The UAW represents many facets of the manufacturing industry (John Deere, Boeing, Kohler) and those companies are doing very well, so please do not put the blame on the UAW and the assembly line workers at the Big 3 for what has happened. My biggest fear is this: Are we going to see our wages/benefits fall more in line with TMMTX and TMMA in the near future ? They are paid way less than TMMK and TMMWV....hum ?????

    Posted By: johnwilliams (6:59am 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    I think the most important part of this article has been overlooked. Regardless of everyones personal opinions about organized labor, the workers at this plant do have the right to talk to their co-workers about organizing a union. They also have the right to file a complaint with the NLRB when they feel their rights have been violated. These rights are for everyone not just the employees refered to in this article. If you decide to exercise your rights in your workplace and your employer violates your rights, please know, you can stand up for your rights! In my opinion thats the American way! Also, please observe the rules listed above the small box used for posting comments,this will be helpful in facilitating good communication. Good luck to the employees at TMMWV and to any other workers in their quest to better their workplace as they see appropriate, it is their workplace. God bless the United States of America and her people!

    Posted By: Ohkan3 (6:41am 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Unions can only do two things for workers, strike and collect dues. Everything else comes from the employer. If this plant is unionized it will be the beginning of the end.

    Posted By: SamCogar (4:58am 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Now,...do your homework and check out the SEIU web site. I think you could learn there and health care was was probably THE most profitable industry in the US last year....just ask your stock broker....lol.

    pipedreams57, why ask a stockbroker? Ask the people who are being forced to pay the horrendous cost of healthcare. Ask the people who have had to file for bankruptcy because of medical bills. Ask Congress why Medicare and Medicaid are floundering in a sea of debt, graft, corruption and outright theft. Just ask Obama and the Democrats why they want a new Health Care Bill.

    Given the above, SEIU should be THE most profitable industry in the US last year. But at what “fleecing” cost to the public?

    Posted By: SamCogar (4:28am 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    @AaronS. Toyota as much an American car as Ford? Surely you jest? Ford's World Headquarters is in Mich.,

    BUT, …. BUT, …. gmhoover, and how do you know that the Ford vehicle you drive was not built in Canada?

    @rwc. It is not where the parts come from....it's where the dollars go! The tax revenues from Ford stay here....tax revenues from Toyota go to Japan.

    UH, …. UH, …. gmhoover, I will assume that was a typo error on your part, RIGHT.

    Or did you mean that the tax revenues from Toyota goes to Japan via way of Washington, DC, to pay the interest on the money that our Government has borrowed from the Japanese government?

    Posted By: SamCogar (4:04am 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    What I want to know is how that’s any different the Rite Aid working employees for 28 days, sending the home for a week and then calling them back for another 3 weeks simply to keep them out of the union? Or different then UPS working employees part time on split shifts for years before giving them a chance to join the union the full time. "

    And it is no different than what Kroger has done for years n’ years. Many of their employees are part-timers with no benefits …… working side-by-side with Union employees.

    Posted By: SamCogar (4:03am 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    My parents both worked in the sweat shop carpet mills in Georgia for many years for little more than minimum wage there "wvuametz" . My father was a college educated accountant and mother was a quality control inspector. Together they managed to eat out once a month and pay the rent but that was about all. Fortunately they both managed to move back here and retire.

    UH, …. UH, ….pipedreams57, …. and just why did your college educated father and your mother take off down Hillbilly Highway to Georgia?

    Do you think you could tell us why they did that? Why they just up and left these beautiful green mountains in West Virginia to eek out a living in Georgia? Seems to me a college educated person would have been smarter than to just up and leave these beautiful green mountains behind.

    Posted By: barbarian (2:31am 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Good! its about time!! we need to unionize everyone from the paper carriers and wal-mart clerks and everyone else!!

    Posted By: uaw1002 (2:04am 11-08-2009)
    Report Abuse


    stand strong with your coworkers and let your voices be heard TMMWV workers! be respectful of coworkers whom fear forming their OWN union. educate educate educate........

    *for the workers at TMMWV that do not want to form their own union, research and educate your self. the united auto workers union IS NOT A 3RD PARTY ENTITY. they will not come to your plant and negotiate a contract for them, BUT YOU WILL NEGOTIATE A CONTRACT FOR YOU AND YOUR COWORKERS, that is if you do decide to stand with your coworkers to form a union!
    as i read the comments posted about what a union or namely the UAW will do if the workers decide to card check, i found a lot of lies or misinformed comments....... i am a UAW MEMBER and i have a voice at my workplace. my workplace is thriving. my plant is hiring and currently working overtime to satisfy our customers. we, at my plant, work hand in hand with management. we want our company to be the best, both company and union employees!
    SOLIDARITY! UNION YES!

    Posted By: ToyotaTM (9:53pm 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    There are three camps currently at the Buffalo plant.

    Camp one is stongly pro-union. They are the loudest of the union supporters and are proud of it.

    Camp two is strongly anti-union. They are as strongly against the union organizers as the company.

    Camp three is riding the fence. They are smart enough to see what happened to the Big 3 and know that there is enough blame to go around. They're gonna do what is best for them and thier families be it pro or anti union.

    You can't pin the failure of the big 3 on the blue collar crowd. Corporate planning put all the eggs in the SuV/Truck basket and when gas prices soared they failed. They had no viable car/crossover products to capitalize on the swing to fuel efficient vehicles. Toyota is famous for quality and fuel efficency. They sale cars based solely on that reputation. Sometimes even when a comparable US made car is less expensive, equal quality, and more fuel efficient.

    The UAW will not organize TMMWV anytime soon.

    Posted By: One Citizen (9:48pm 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Toyota has long "survived" auto unions in Japan

    Toyota unions eye ¥1,000 raise

    Saturday, Jan. 19, 2008

    NAGOYA (Kyodo) The federation of labor unions of Toyota Motor Corp. group companies plan to seek a base pay increase of at least ¥1,000 in this year's "shunto" spring wage negotiations, federation officials said Friday.

    It will be the first time in six years that the Federation of All Toyota Workers' Unions has demanded a hike in the basic monthly wage with a specific figure.

    The umbrella body, consisting of 292 unions with 290,000 members, will finalize the plan at a meeting starting in Tokyo on Friday.

    Among the unions under the federation, the Toyota Motor Workers' Union plans to demand a ¥1,500 pay increase.

    The plan is in line with the decision by the Confederation of Japan Automobile Workers' Unions, the industrywide umbrella body, to demand a pay hike of ¥1,000 or more.

    MORE HERE

    http://tinyurl.com/yfd3boh

    Posted By: observer1 (9:10pm 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Woo hoo!

    A union brings more than just higher wages and better benefits. It brings respect! It means dignity.

    Solidarity and good luck!

    Posted By: AaronS (8:50pm 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    General Motors, bailed out by the US government and still went bankrupt.

    Chrysler bailed out by the US Government and still went bankrupt.

    Ford was saved by overseas production or they would have been bailed out by the US Government and went bankrupt.

    Union. yea...

    Posted By: pipedreams57 (8:09pm 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    For bennysaunders89 : Most hospitals in WV, OH, KY,and many other states are staffed with union labor from the SEIU. Now,...do your homework and check out the SEIU web site. I think you could learn there and health care was was probably THE most profitable industry in the US last year....just ask your stock broker....lol.

    Posted By: pipedreams57 (8:02pm 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    I posted one of the first comments here on this story. Checking back today I see it has turned into a war or opinions. I have one thing left to say. I'm 52 years old, born in WV, and still own a home and property there. I worked the first 11 years of my life as a highly skilled laborer for the 9th largest company in the world [oil], before being promoted into management. I was trained in many topics, personnel management, production efficiency, etc. I learned all the secret loopholes in labor lawand was grilled and drilled on how to subvert and derail union activity. It was a dirty, deceitful, disgusting, dishonorable schooling. I no longer work in WV because there are no jobs there that pay what I make by traveling anywhere and everywhere. I have worked with workers of many unions such as UAW, UMWA,Teamsters,PACE,SEIU,and others. I have also worked as management for several major corporations. Union jobs are better jobs. Toyota must obey US labor law,.or pack for Japan. Union yes!

    Posted By: bennysaunders89 (7:34pm 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Dear Union Supporters,
    Please cite, in specific examples, one major long-term unionized industrial operation in West Virginia that is both currently profitable and not subsidized by the United States government in any way.
    Thanks,
    Not Morons Everywhere

    Posted By: American12 (7:01pm 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    No, I assume these workers know what is going on at their work. If they want a union it is up to them to make that decision. We don't know what they go through but should respect they know their own environment. I assume these workers expect their rights to be respected while at work. I assume these workers are tired of not sharing in the huge success they have participated in for Toyota. Isn't it curious why a company like this would welcome unionized workers at home in Japan and maintain a productive relationship with them for many years, but come to the US and fight their own employees and deny them the rights in this country? Do you think they tell the Japan workers that they can't talk about the union while on break? Why does it seem reasonable to some on here that this company signs a contract with every business relationship it has except for the people who do the work? Go Buffalo workers, go!!

    Posted By: AaronS (6:28pm 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    You're assuming facts not in evidence 12.

    Posted By: American12 (6:05pm 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    My, My, what has happened to you all? Read the article. It says Toyota is breaking the law and violating these workers rights. Why can't they talk to each other and pass information during their breaks and lunch? Is Toyota more important than our labor laws now? And! And if you all accept that Toyota would close the place and move simply because these good workers want thier working conditions and related wages and benefits in writing, you again condone another violation of the laws here. It is against the law to close a wokplac because the workers choose to unionize. If Toyota is going to be a criminal, then they should get the hell out and not sell cars here either. As long as they are here, follow our laws. What;s wrong with workers improving their factory? Telling them to leave if they don't like it fixes nothing. If the laws in your community are broken do you try to enforce them and correct the situation or do you just move to another town?

    Posted By: AaronS (6:02pm 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    [i]Given a choice,,,,I will support a true American company!
    [/i]

    Then I’m not sure what you’re going to drive. Ford’s headquarters may be in Michigan but their profits come from overseas manufacturing, primarily Asia. It’s the only reason Ford wasn’t forced to take stimulus money to begin with as their US facilities lose just as much as GM and Chrysler and as such, their tax burden is lessened.

    As for Toyota, it is a subsidiary of a foreign owned company and is taxed as such. The way I see it, if it’s made in West Virginia by West Virginians and TMMWV pays taxes here, which they do, it’s a US car. And on top of that, they pay MORE taxes to the state of West Virginia then Ford does so they’re BETTER for West Virginia then Ford is.

    Posted By: Dawg (5:16pm 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    There is one simple solution to work. If you don't like your job then go get a new one. I work at TMMWV and there are things I don't like at the plant, like working nightshift, but if I get to the point that I can't stand working there any longer, I will find another job. I don't need a union to stand for my rights. I can stand on my own rights.

    Posted By: Grouse (4:59pm 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    A union would be the death knell for this plant. In a few years it would be closed with the jobs transferred to Mexico.

    Posted By: gmhoover (3:43pm 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    @rwc. It is not where the parts come from....it's where the dollars go! The tax revenues from Ford stay here....tax revenues from Toyota go to Japan. Now...that's not true for the workers...but it is true for the corporation. As far as Harley D goes....forget it...I would rather buy a Victory. They are more an American company than Harley!

    Posted By: wvaproud (3:33pm 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Ask the workers at Century Aluminum in R'wood how they like their union...oh, wait, ya' can't! Ok, bye...

    Posted By: rwc (3:28pm 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Given a choice,,,,I will support a true American company!GM HOOVER,i don't know where you've been,but you show me an american made car.parts to all these cars,no matter if they have american names ,are assembled here but not fully made here.toyota is no different.harley davidson cannot even claim that.

    Posted By: smarbap (2:45pm 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    What a bunch of ingrates these pro-union employees are!

    And, not content with facilitating the financial implosion of GM and Chrysler, the UAW now has its sights set upon any auto manufacturing facility in the U.S., regardless of its ownership.

    The solution for Toyota is simple: Shut down all U.S. manufacturing facilities and relocate them within countries in which workers remain dedicated to their duties--NOT to their "rights".

    Posted By: WVState (2:45pm 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Did you read the article? Toyota pays union style wages to keep the union out. If it wasn't for the union that others belong to, the wages would not be so good at Toyota.

    Read the comments below from people who work there. Obviously it's not such a great job as it was a few years ago. Salaries are being cut. If Toyota is doing such a good job with its employees, it would have nothing to fear in letting people pass out union literature.

    It's a simple choice. It really doesn't help your relations with your staff if you act like you want to keep things from them. They won't join the union if they have nothing to gain.

    Posted By: gmhoover (2:04pm 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    @AaronS. Toyota as much an American car as Ford? Surely you jest? Ford's World Headquarters is in Mich., Toyota's is in Japan. Corporate profits creates tax revenues too. Toyota builds a fine vehicle...but, no better than Ford does. Given a choice,,,,I will support a true American company!

    Posted By: AaronS (12:48am 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    My mistake. Toyota only has one union plant and that is in California. In August of this year, they halved the jobs at NUMMI and moved them to Canada to a non-union facility.

    Below gmhoover talks of how Toyota uses Manpower to work employees at reduced wages and this is true. Manpower got the contract about 5 or 6 years ago and that became their focal point of business.

    What I want to know is how that’s any different the Rite Aid working employees for 28 days, sending the home for a week and then calling them back for another 3 weeks simply to keep them out of the union? Or different then UPS working employees part time on split shifts for years before giving them a chance to join the union the full time.

    The point is, Toyota isn't doing anything that UNIONS in this valley weren't already doing when they came to town.

    The employees can unionize but nothing can force Toyota to stay in Buffalo and card check won't change that.

    Posted By: AaronS (12:28am 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    I still say that American labor builds the finest automobiles in the world. I always enjoy asking people I meet at repair shops : Unemployed? Hungry? Kids need new shoes? EAT YOUR TOYOTA !!!

    Toyota has 13 manufacturing facilities in the United States, 3 of which are already union, thus in my humble opinion, Toyota is as much an American car as Ford is.

    Posted By: gmhoover (11:45am 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Most of you that have read my comments over time know that I am a conservative. I have worked at TMMWV. I can honestly say that there are two sides to this story. The full time team member, team leaders and managers are all doing and receiving fair compensation easily comparable to the big three in Detroit. However, Toyota has lied and abused the agreement between the full time team members and the part time associates. More than 10% of the workers in the plant are part-time associates who sometimes work for years before earning even an interview. These workers work side by side on the assembly line, performing the same jobs as the full time team members, making far less than half the wage. Manpower has made millions off of these workers....I don't see where that is any different than a union. Tim Smith is a good man. And yes, he had a union background before going to TMMWV. But, Toyota has not kept their agreements, and the workers deserve a voice.

    Posted By: Mary Johnson (11:35am 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    I applaud Tim and his co-workers for standing up to managements illegal 'union bashing' attempts to deny workers their legal rights under the NLRA. Having been involved in our UAW union drive at Foxwoods Casino in CT., we stood strong against the anti-union tactics used by managements union bashing hired guns Jackson-Lewis and Russ Brown Assoc. and are very close to having our 1st contract.
    It is more important now, than ever, for workers to stand together, to protect ourselves and our families with fair contracts. Toyota management are puppets to the corporate greed permeating throughout America today. As citizens and workers of this great country, I say...enough is enough....we are fighting mad!! Go get them Toyota workers! GO UAW!!
    (P.S.- all you anti-union posters...take your head out of the sand to what is happening in our country today! You should be ashamed of yourselves!!)

    Posted By: kdmc47 (11:33am 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Go ahead pay these people union dues so they can live the big life. Kiss your jobs good-bye. Look what the unions have done to the so-called Big 3. Go ahead and get in the unemployment line.

    Posted By: wvu80 (10:29am 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Better keep the unions away!!They will cost you your jobs. Refuse their literature and tell them to leave you alone!

    Posted By: Vito (10:07am 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Toyota Employees before joining "any" organized labor union take your own survey of unions in the state. Ask why other non union company employees are NOT joining a union !

    Ask why coal mine employees at all non union coal mines are NOT joining a union ! Then ask "any" UMW representative why they CANNOT organize these non union companies !

    Ask why non union freight and small package trucking company employees are NOT joining a union ! Then ask "any" Teamster union representative why they CANNOT organize "any" non union trucking company !

    And last but not least. Ask the author of this story ( Paul Nyden) about why he has never written any articles of corruption in unions ? He claims he is a "investigative" reporter ! The ask Nyden why the very newspaper he represents does NOT have union employees ? Then ask Nyden why he has such a "close" tied association with UMW and Teamster representatives ?

    Why ? Paul Nyden carries these unions water to promote their socialist agendas !

    Posted By: True WV (9:57am 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    @ Union Yes...Unions are what they started out fighting. Unions are big business. The union bosses are like the corporate CEO's. Their main goal is to maintain their huge income and lifestyle. They could care less about the union worker. Neither side in the battle cares about the union worker.

    Posted By: True WV (9:49am 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    get ready to say bye bye Toyoto

    Posted By: wvpride (8:33am 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    I am a Toyota employee in Buffalo WV, I enjoy what I do, I like my company also. But I have no say in my future here, Toyota has been taking from us the past 3 or 4 years, I'm making less now than I did 3 years ago. Toyota's profits have been booming and its because of us. We make the product for Toyota, I believe if a Company is profitable than we should be also.

    Posted By: CAPTAINJOE (7:48am 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Toyota plant in buffalo doesn't have anything to worry about unless they follow through on their plan to CUT EMPLOYEES WAGES as this article stated.
    How many of you would be happy to have your wages cut?
    Hopefully they only emulated the good business practices of big three. Hopefully they haven't followed the big threes lead when it comes to management pay.
    However, When you are throwing 6 figure salaries around like candy to a few (LIKE THE BIG THREE) and complaining that you have to pay your workers $40-50K your not going to get any sympathy from me.
    Hopefully they are going to keep their uncanny sense for attention to detail. Thats the main reason I bought a toyota last year. QUALITY!

    Point is, if they are treating their workers ok, the Union won't be necessary. IF they start cutting salaries and benefits, they will open the door for the unions THEMSELVES.

    Posted By: sadsam (7:26am 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Sign that union card and kiss that great job goodby you idiots. Toyota will run away and who blames them. Unions suck and they only benefit those who run them.

    Posted By: jimwire (7:05am 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    The United Auto workers are a much greater threat to America than Osama Ben Ladin Paying union dues is like peeing in the wind or throwing your money in the ocean

    Posted By: Leroy Lipship (6:32am 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Oh my, WV is running off another manufacturer that pays high wages and good benefits! Maybe it would serve the state right for Toyota to just pick up and move to a grateful state!

    Posted By: wvuametz (3:06am 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    I love the sob stories from the union folks who act as if it's still 1950. Not everyone is going to be successful, pipe smoker. That's life.

    Sorry your "educated" folks couldn't do better and find better work. It's a free country....an accountant and inspector should be able to go somewhere else. And I have a feeling that carpet mills are far different from automobile plants.

    Also, when was that sob story? 1970ish? I have a feeling things have changed. Sure, there are bad jobs and bad environments, but it’s the freedom as a citizen of the USA to find better and make better for yourself.

    To sum up: Bad job? Go get a better one. Unions just make the economy worse and stifle the free market. Good companies will pay what you’re worth. Unions will force good companies to pay crap like they’re the best ever.

    Posted By: sportsFIXU4 (1:54am 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Yep, they don't need us- Jay got this for WV and if they install a strong union then this plant will go out of business just like the stamp plant-I talk to several workers and they have had no problems - this is far from a sweat shop-
    With the attack on coal coming I really don't know what is going to support our goverment-
    It would be so nice to ride the tide until the encon gets moving again-

    Posted By: pipedreams57 (12:53am 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    My parents both worked in the sweat shop carpet mills in Georgia for many years for little more than minimum wage there "wvuametz" . My father was a college educated accountant and mother was a quality control inspector. Together they managed to eat out once a month and pay the rent but that was about all. Fortunately they both managed to move back here and retire. You need to work one of those "right to work" jobs in Dalton Georgia for a year and send me a note as to how you like working 70 hours a week in 110 degree heat sucking down a lung full of carpet lint every day. If labor unions didn't set the wage precedent for a lot of industries out there, we would all be working for peanuts.

    Posted By: wvuametz (12:48am 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Wow.....Thanks for your input, Michael Moore! Now, back to reality.

    Yeah.....so why are the factories that are non-union doing so well? And always have done well?

    Unions strangle free markets and add artificial restrictions, plainand simple. So start your union, and watch the jobs leave the area to go down south.

    Of course, in Obama's economy, I guess job loss would be just about the status quo....So Go For It!!

    Posted By: pipedreams57 (12:38am 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    I think the "big 3" put themselves out of business with a little shove from programs like NAFTA. They priced themselves out of business and admitted to allowing shoddy parts and assembly practices to continue for years, but as long as corporate fat cat salaries and bonuses flowed nobody cared. Maybe the big 3 have learned a valuable lesson. I hope so, because I still refuse to own any of the alternatives. I still say that American labor builds the finest automobiles in the world. I always enjoy asking people I meet at repair shops : Unemployed? Hungry? Kids need new shoes? EAT YOUR TOYOTA !!! Always remember Batan when you celebrate Veterans Day!

    Posted By: WEST VIRGINIAN (12:18am 11-07-2009)
    Report Abuse


    "Toyota workers in Buffalo talking union"

    nnn

    The 'key' word is "talking". The employees @ Toyota are too intelligent to join the UAW, which has put the 'BIG THREE' out of business.

    Advertisement - Your ad here
    PRECISION TUNE
    Precision Tune Auto Care is the fast, convenient and affordable solution to all of your car repai...
    Advertisement - Your ad here
    Inside wvgazette.com