November 21, 2009
Comparing Pitt, WVU; Heisman and focus
Advertiser

A FEW thoughts:

  • At the beginning of the season, I never thought I'd be writing the following sentence.
  • But West Virginia's football team is a Pitt wannabe.

    Well, at least, the Mountaineers should want to be like Pitt. They should want to have shown the improvement of the Panthers.

    Look around the two teams.

    Heading into the season, every analyst thought Pitt might be dragged down by quarterback Bill Stull. Instead, he's exhibited vast improvement and, heading into the weekend, was the nation's No. 4 QB in terms of passing efficiency. WVU's Jarrett Brown has suffered from various nicks. Still, there's been little, if any, improvement in his play.

    You could almost point to any aspect of Pitt's team and see improvement over the season. Heck, throw out Panthers tailback sensation Dion Lewis, who entered the weekend as the nation's No. 6 rusher, as an anomaly if you wish.

    Check Pittsburgh's receivers, the development of Jonathan Baldwin and the nice way the Panther coaches are using tight end Dorin Dickerson. Compare it to the static play of West Virginia's receiving corps.

    Both Pitt lines have been impressive. West Virginia's, not so much.

    One could go on and on. Look at the teams' linebackers. The point, though, is this: Before the season one could legitimately say West Virginia had as much, if not more, talent than Pitt. Now, the way the Panthers have grown and the Mountaineers have not, one cannot make the same claim.

  • I received my Heisman Trophy ballot in the mail the other day. For the curious, the ballots must be cast no later than 5 p.m. on Dec. 7, which is a Monday.
  • Most, at least those most responsible, will hold off to vote until the last moment.

    I have, however, started to zero in on some of the nation's better players. (Yes, I do my own homework; no, I do not rely on Rece Davis, Craig James, Kirk Herbstreit or, God forbid, Jesse Palmer to inform me of my decision.)

    Up to Saturday's games, my list had been pared to 14.

    Alabama running back Mark Ingram? He's certainly received all the publicity of late. But in my eyes he's been second to Stanford senior battering ram Toby Gerhart. And if one is throwing love to Ingram, toss a little to Pitt's Lewis as well.

    If you like your Heisman winner to throw the ball, three have jumped out: Arkansas' Ryan Mallet, Notre Dame's Jimmy Clausen and Boise State's Kellen Moore - not necessarily in that order.

    Report a violation or offensive comment.
    [X] Close
    to report abuse.
    Posted By: umwaeer (2:07pm 11-23-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Mitch I'm glad one of our guys is not drone for ESPN propaganda machine. You can't call it what it is but they pay the big bucks to the SEC and will shamelessly promote them. Mark is the only one working amoung that group that tries to provide some semblance of objectivity. I personally think Bill Stull, from Pitt, Kellen Moore from Boise St and Jerry Hughes from TCU are the three most worthy players in this years class. Hughes is heads a group of defensive players of which Pitt has a couple to fit the bill. Kellen Moore is the best combination of QB and leader in this class, and Stull is getting very good results with the one of the best offensive lines in the country, the best freshman running back and the best wide receivers/tightends in the conference if not the country on any single college team.

    Posted By: wvu1980 (2:50pm 11-22-2009)
    Report Abuse


    Pitt and Cincy are the leagues best teams, by far.
    Usf, WVU, uCONN, Rutgers are average.
    Lville and Syracuse terrible.

    Posted By: happyeer (2:40pm 11-22-2009)
    Report Abuse


    meathead is going nowhere, and he won't hold any of his assistants accoutable. So, if they want, the entire staff will be back next year.And the destruction continues.
    Our coaches demand less, so we get less.
    Winning must be first and foremost. That isn't the case. Hugs and straing is the key to success. Congradulating and praising the opposing team, laughing and having a good time on the sidelines while your team is getting pounded.
    i don['t think meathead understands the responsbilites and duties of a head coach. Over his long career, he had hardly ever been one, and that time , he was fired.
    Pitt will be us friday ,and badly. Stew will tell us how good pitt is, and their staff, and we must recommit ourselves to hugging and straining more.
    DOESN'T THIS ACT START TO GET OLD HAT?

    Posted By: umwaeer (2:18pm 11-22-2009)
    Report Abuse


    On paper Pitt has recruited better than anyone in the Big East every year for the last 4 years. They are more talented, and now with Cignetti as their OC will become the dominant team everyone expected them to become when Wandstedt was hired. He was given autonomy to run the offense and has been very successful with the tools available to him, which are the best in the Big East. Stull himself was not highly rated coming out of highschool. However, "potential" was the descriptive used by everyone because of his size and arm strength. He has been well coached. Cignetti gets results! Pitts defensive talent is the best in the Big East, is better coached, therefore, will give the ball to their offense more often. WVU has never had the best talent in the Big East and never will, however, beginning with 2010, we hold Bill accountable. Thats when his recruits begin to fill the starting roster. 2010 he will have his first junior in the lineup.

    Advertisement - Your ad here
    Advertisement - Your ad here
    SILVERSTEIN MADDOX  & WALLACE
    Silverstein, Maddox, Wallace & Associates Insurance has over 50 years experience handling ins...
    Advertisement - Your ad here