October 20, 2009
State cars: Tax-provided plums
Advertiser

Back in the bad old days, people with political connections got Statehouse jobs at taxpayer expense -- and luckier ones also got free state cars to drive.

This tax-funded featherbedding supposedly was reduced by rising professionalism and Civil Service. However, some cushy car benefits remain under the golden dome.

Few businesses give employees company cars to drive home at night. In the private sector, most workers, even executives, pay for their own commuting. But 29 state agencies let government officials commute in cars from the state's fleet of nearly 7,000 vehicles. It's a lucrative "perk" in these days of sky-high gasoline cost, with taxpayers footing the bill.

If a bureaucrat uses his state car more than half the time for personal driving, IRS rules require him to declare this boon as income -- equal to the lease price of the auto -- and pay taxes on it. If the car is used more than half the time for state business, the official must pay tax on just $3 per day commuting benefit.

A new state audit found that nobody knows exactly how many cars are owned by the state. And most agencies don't require bureaucrats to record their mileage, so it's impossible to know whether a state car is used more than half the time for personal driving.

Worse, the audit found that 90 state officials -- including Treasurer John Perdue and Agriculture Commissioner Gus Douglass -- don't pay taxes on the extra income afforded by their free state cars. We hope IRS inspectors scrutinize the auditor's list carefully.

Statehouse columnist Phil Kabler recounted that former Gov. Gaston Caperton once banned personal use of state autos after some Turnpike employees took Turnpike vehicles on hunting-fishing trips to Kentucky on state time. But Caperton's ban didn't last. Also, former Gov. Bob Wise ordered a 10 percent reduction in the state fleet, to save taxpayers money.

Currently, the state pays between $60 million and $70 million yearly for vehicles, including $24 million for gasoline. Is all this outlay needed for government operations -- or does part of it provide bureaucrat plums?

We remember when longtime Statehouse politico Curtis Sutphin was fired because he wrecked his state auto in Ohio. Other car outrages popped in the news occasionally. Why should taxpayers keep paying for such expensive abuses?

Does the state government really need 7,000 cars at $65 million yearly cost? If nightly commuting were halted, how much would taxpayers save? A legislative committee should get some answers for the people.

Report a violation or offensive comment.
[X] Close
to report abuse.
Posted By: jd1smith (10:10am 10-25-2009)
Report Abuse


isn't this the same group justifying the costs for the state plane because it would be inconvient for the governor to ride in a car to Martinsburg. How many cars does King Joe have on his staff and what restrictions are imposed?

How many times are individuals told to get on the register, a job is posted and then they are hired.

A new postion is created and a preferential employee is hired into this postion with a pay raise and no new duties.

If this and other papers would do some investigative reporting rather than write the "state auditors reported".

Rather than being watchdogs, the media in this state protects the administration and occassionally point out some flaw affecting rank and file employees but never critizes the head of government for its corrupt practices.

Posted By: Earned_My_Degree (10:17pm 10-23-2009)
Report Abuse


I guess I'm too busy minding my own business to spend much time surveying the license plates in the parking lot.

Posted By: rcj112 (10:07am 10-23-2009)
Report Abuse


I can't even begin to count the times I've pulled in a shopping center & saw a car with state license plates on it. I'm sure they're not buying the bosses work clothes.

Posted By: AaronS (6:50am 10-22-2009)
Report Abuse


The answer is so simple it’s no wonder state government employees can't think of it. If a person uses a car less then 50% of the time for state business, there is no reason they should be issued a car so take those cars away from individuals and put them in motor pools.

When those people need a vehicle, they go to the motor pool, sign one out and return it to the motor pool upon completion of their job.

For those who rarely use a state car, simply reimburse them the federally accepted rate for the mileage on their vehicle. I believe that is currently $.53 per mile. Force them to turn in a mileage voucher and sign it stating that they used their vehicle for state business and pay them.

And for the very small minority that require a state car for their business, force them to keep track of all miles traveled, differentiate between personal and business and they reimburse the state for personal miles traveled at the same rate.

See how simple that is.

Advertisement - Your ad here
Advertisement - Your ad here
MC CORMICK JEWELERS
A name you have know and trusted for over 60 years for honesty, quality and fair prices. The own...
Advertisement - Your ad here