WVGAZETTE.COM/POLITICS
print | email | size
November 4, 2008
McCain takes Mountain State
Arizona senator makes W.Va. a red state third election in a row

CHARLESTON, W.Va. -- John McCain carried West Virginia in the presidential election Tuesday, marking the third straight election where voters in the once reliably Democrat state have picked a Republican for the nation's highest office.

Democrat Barack Obama won the election, but McCain took the Mountain State by double digits. With 70 percent of precincts reporting late Tuesday, McCain led about 55 percent to 45 percent.

Obama had trailed in pre-election polls in West Virginia, and Sen. Hillary Clinton trounced him by a 2-1 margin in the state's Democratic primary in May.

At Embassy Suites in Charleston on Tuesday night, Republicans watched local and national elections as they gathered to support state candidates. 

Shortly after 9 p.m., the Democratic Illinois senator had twice as many electoral votes as McCain. Half an hour earlier, Fox News had projected that Obama had won the key battleground state of Pennsylvania.  

"I can't control what goes on in the rest of the country," said Ben Beakes, director of McCain's West Virginia campaign. "We did our job, and the people of West Virginia made the right choice."

Beakes called Obama's views on social issues such as abortion and gun rights "radical."

"When you get down to the presidential election, West Virginia values are solid," he said.

He also said Obama and running mate Joe Biden are "enemies of coal." The McCain campaign recently had tried to sway coal state voters by quoting from a 10-month-old interview to allege that Obama plans to "bankrupt the coal industry" with his plan to limit greenhouse gas emissions.

A block away, Democrats gathered at the Marriott with Gov. Joe Manchin and other state political leaders.

Despite polls, Obama campaign officials had called West Virginia "a battleground" throughout the campaign.

Tom Vogel, director of Obama's West Virginia campaign, said Republicans misconstrued Obama's views on many issues.

"I believe that when we have President Obama, [West Virginia voters] will see that those statements are false," Vogel said. "They'll realize that Democrats aren't going to take away their guns. They'll realize they support coal."

Partygoers appeared jubilant at the Marriott, where people jammed into a ballroom to watch three big-screen TVs. 

Some booed when CNN projected McCain's win in West Virginia.

Only moments later, the crowd erupted in screams and waved campaign signs as the network declared that Obama had won in Ohio.

Woody Woods, a D.J. from Charleston, grinned widely and exclaimed, "Yes we can!"

"I feel like it's New Year's Eve, Christmas and my birthday, mixed all together," Woods said.

This was the first year Woods, 28, ever voted.

"People might say I'm voting because I'm a black male," he said. "I'm voting because I believe he's the better candidate out of the two ... I voted because we needed a change."

He said he liked Obama's stance on issues such as health care. He also said he felt emotional knowing he would soon be able to tell his 9-year-old daughter that a black person could be president.

With McCain's West Virginia victory, the debate is over about whether President George W. Bush's wins in the state were aberrations, said Robert Rupp, a political history professor at West Virginia Wesleyan College.

"Until 2000, West Virginia was one of the most loyal Democratic states in presidential election history," Rupp said. "They stood by Carter in '80. They stood by Dukakis in '88 ... In a sense, what's happened is that we've lost the legend of being a loyal Democratic state in presidential elections."

West Virginia could now be seen as a "split-level state," with Democrats dominating at the state and local levels but Republicans winning presidential elections, Rupp said.

That's due in large part to the socially conservative views of many West Virginians, said Neil Berch, a political science professor at West Virginia University.

"[State Democratic] candidates are not running on the same platform as say Sen. Obama, or at least many of them are not," Berch said.

West Virginia's turning red also is part of a larger national realignment spurred by demographic shifts, he said.

Rupp said Republicans had hoped Bush's two victories here would stimulate the creation of a GOP infrastructure in state politics. Democrats wanted their voters to return to straight-ticket voting.

Tuesday's results showed that neither happened.

Neither presidential candidate spent much time in the state; McCain made a couple of brief appearances.

Obama's campaign sent Biden to Charleston in October. Former President Bill Clinton stumped for Obama at a rally in Beckley on Saturday.

It appeared the Obama campaign laid the infrastructure and put staffing in place in West Virginia in case the state turned into a battleground - but it never became one, Rupp said. 

"Although the Obama campaign did spend resources," he said, "the key fact is that the candidate himself did not come."

He said that likely influenced many voters.

"As an Appalachian state, we like to get attention, we like to see our candidates up close," he said.

Without getting to know Obama, many voters probably went for the "default" of McCain, he said.

Media reports focused heavily on race in West Virginia, where 95 percent of the population is white. Rupp said a study of the returns would be the only way to know how much a role race played in voters' decision.

However, he said many West Virginians' rejection of Obama was not so much "blatant racism" as it was a reflection of Appalachian culture - one that is suspicious of outsiders and wary of change.

Southern Ohio and southwestern Pennsylvania also are part of that landscape, he said. 

"It isn't the state of West Virginia," he said. "It's the political culture of Appalachia that had some concerns or suspicions of the Obama campaign."

Rupp said he believes Hillary Clinton would have beaten McCain in West Virginia in a landslide.

"This state loved Bill Clinton, and Hillary Clinton proved herself to be an able campaigner," Rupp said.

Berch, though, said the New York senator's platform was too similar to Obama's to have won the state. 

"I think, most likely, she would not have won West Virginia," he said. "She probably would have done a little better" than Obama.

Reach Alison Knezevich at alis...@wvgazette.com or 348-1240.

Report a violation or offensive comment.
[X] Close
to report abuse.
Posted By: WVHillbilly (10:51pm 11-08-2008)
Report Abuse


. . . which only proves that WV is a state of backwoods losers.

Posted By: Red Dragon 70 (12:59am 11-08-2008)
Report Abuse


So many of you seem to suggest that bigoted positions because of religion is OK, while conceding that bigotry because of race is not acceptable. Am I hearing you correctly? It seems to me that religious intolerance is "right up there" with racial intolerance!

Posted By: jes (8:05am 11-07-2008)
Report Abuse


The people of WV still have morals because McCain took this state? After receiving tons of emails from family and friends about how Obama is the anti-christ and hearing that he really is a secret muslim from several people as well, I don't think it was an issue of morals. If you call THAT behavior "morals", I've got a bridge for sale. Actually I have to say, that when McCain gave his speech the other night I pointed at the screen and said "That's the man I wanted for office. Where in hades was he during this whole election process?". The man giving that speech, was who I wanted for President. Before this I figured McCain was above muckraking, especially after his round with Bush. Morals? Nah.

Posted By: dubVladiii (7:53am 11-07-2008)
Report Abuse


and J you are absolutely right...

Advertiser

It's easy to follow the top stories with home delivery of The Charleston Gazette.

Click here to order home delivery.

Advertiser
More Politics
High court's elimination of juvenile referees in court system criticized
As news spread this week that the West Virginia Supreme Court had eliminated the position of juvenile referee, some judges and others questioned what that will mean for teenagers in the criminal justice system.
Public comment period for vote-by-mail program
West Virginia residents can comment on a state pilot project that will expand voting by mail in elections.
McDowell delegate vows to stop traffic to protest tolls
For at least one lawmaker, the fight over toll increases on the 88-mile West Virginia Turnpike is not over.
West Virginia charitable pharmacy gets mail-order drug license
A state board says a charitable pharmacy started by Gov. Joe Manchin has become the first of its type in the state to be licensed to ship mail-order prescriptions.
Judge orders monitor on mental health issues
The state will spend millions of dollars on new group homes, day treatment programs, jobs at psychiatric hospitals and other items associated with mental health care under an agreement reached Thursday.
Carte Goodwin may run for Congress
Carte Goodwin, general counsel for Gov. Joe Manchin during his first term between 2005 and 2009, is thinking about running for the congressional seat held by Rep. Shelley Moore Capito, R-W.Va., since 2000.
New prisons, shorter sentences recommended to reduce Corrections system overcrowding
A governor's commission submitted 14 short- and long-term recommendations to alleviate overcrowding in state prisons on Wednesday.
W.Va. ends tough budget year on hopeful fiscal notes
CHARLESTON, W.Va. -- West Virginia has ended its budget year with a trio of positive signs for state government's finances, but the recession and other factors overshadow each fiscal indicator.
Turnpike toll hike approved
For passenger vehicles, the hike means an increase from $1.25 to $2 per toll plaza, while the cash rate for commercial trucks will jump from $4.25 to $6.75 per toll plaza.
Turnpike toll hike expected to pass Wednesday
It's all but decided that the state Parkways Authority will approve toll increases on the West Virginia Turnpike on Wednesday. Still to be resolved are the amount of the increase, when it will take effect, and what sorts of discounts may be offered to Turnpike commuters.
Manchin's energy plan among new July 1 laws
BrickStreet Insurance repays state loan
Ag department works to eliminate obsolete laws
The state Department of Agriculture is working to get obsolete agriculture-related laws off the books.
Byrd released from hospital after more than a month
It's still not clear when the longest-serving senator in United States history might return to the Senate.
Speakers blast proposed cut to state retiree benefits
West Virginia will have trouble recruiting and retaining teachers, State Police troopers and other public employees if the Public Employees Insurance Agency cuts the subsidy, speakers said at a public hearing Monday evening.