WVGAZETTE.COM/POLITICS
print | email | size
October 13, 2008
Bars, clubs recovering from county smoking ban

As predicted here weeks ago, bars and clubs around Kanawha County are continuing to regain business lost when the countywide public smoking ban was imposed July 1, based on the only available objective figures to track their business.

Total limited video lottery revenues for the county in September were $3,024,692, up $111,149, or about 4 percent from August, according to the Lottery Commission's monthly report.

In fact, the limited video lottery in bars and clubs in smoke-free Kanawha County outperformed their brethren in the rest of the state.

Statewide, limited video lottery revenue dropped for the month of September, down to $32,901,342 from $34,385,297 in August.

That's a drop of 4.5 percent statewide, which seems consistent with the downturn in consumer and recreational spending nationally.

The top-earning establishment in the county, Mimi's of Nitro, had $97,548 in revenue for September, up 10 percent from $88,516 in August - and up 25 percent from $77,832 in June, the last month smoking was permissible.

And this is for an establishment near the Putnam County line, and part of a chain where the operator was recently quoted as estimating that 80 percent of the clientele were smokers.

So, lo and behold, Kanawha County seems to be following the pattern of every other jurisdiction in the United States that has prohibited smoking in public places: After an initial decline, business rebounds.

Meanwhile, limited video revenues for Putnam County bars and clubs dropped from $552,330 in August to $525,243 in September. Could it be that non-smoking slots players in Putnam County are bypassing their local establishments to take advantage of the smoke-free environs in Kanawha County?

  • nn
  • Senate President Earl Ray Tomblin's objections to locating a large, elaborate visitors information desk at the Capitol Rotunda is well taken.

    The Department of Administration's initial plan would leave only one narrow access to the Journal Room, an area that is already usually crowded and difficult to access, particularly when there are displays or rallies in the rotunda.

    The proposal also calls for drilling a hole into the marble floor of the rotunda, to run phone and computer lines, as well as fiber-optic cable so that Public Broadcasting could televise the last night of the session without having to run a maze of cables through the rotunda area.

  • nn
  • Speaking of the Senate, the Capitol Building Commission approved enclosing the end of the hallway between the Senate chamber and Senate Minority Leader Don Caruth's office to create a room for Senate pages.

    More accurately, the 5-foot by 12-foot room will be where pages will go to fetch coffee and soft drinks for the senators during floor sessions.

  • nn
  • Former West Virginia Education Association assistant executive director Bill McGinley has been hired as an administrative law judge for the state Public Employees Grievance Board.

    McGinley was the fourth WVEA executive to leave the union this year, as it deals with financial issues.

  • nn
  • The state Ethics Commission has elected commissioner Drema Radford as its vice chairwoman. She replaces Jim Shepherd, who was appointed this month to the commission's Probable Cause Review Board, the three-member panel that reviews and investigates complaints filed with the commission.

    Shepherd replaces Holmes Morrison, who resigned during the summer, which under the state ethics law left the board too short-handed to hear complaints.

  • nn
  • Speaking of ethics, commission administrative secretary Lucy Suchy is completing work on a 28-page "Guide to Lobbying in West Virginia," which will be given to all newly registered lobbyists, beginning next session.

    Suchy illustrated the draft of the guide with various interior and exterior shots of the Capitol.

    The cover features a picture of the well of the Capitol rotunda, to the delight of commissioner and former state Sen. Larry Rowe, who knows that that the well serves as the work desk for lobbyists during the session.

  • nn
  • The state Racing Commission will hold a public hearing Tuesday at commission headquarters on the two $1 million greyhound training tracks it has been mandated to build.

  • nn
  • One correction from last week's lobbyist spending reports. It was Walter Gose of Saofi-Aventis of Knoxville, not Joe Gollehon, who helped underwrite the West Virginia Night at the Council of State Governments dinner in Lexington.

  • nn
  • Finally, talk about karmic justice: Could it be more ironic that the Blackhawk Saloon, the bar that had been most public in flaunting Kanawha County's public smoking ban, caught fire - and the patrons didn't realize it at first because of the cigarette smoke.

    Reach Phil Kabler at ph...@wvgazette.com or 348-1220.

    Report a violation or offensive comment.
    [X] Close
    to report abuse.
    Posted By: yogipsk (11:19am 10-31-2008)
    Report Abuse


    I don't know how this us under Phil's area since this has nothing to do with the statehous beat, where by the way, our legislators may smoke in their offices. I have been around to a few bars lately and if they are following the ban they are empty, if they defy it they are rockin'. I'm just wondering where all the fresh air is...because the bars without smoke smell like hell, stale beer and feet, yuck. I think adults can make a choice for themselves about smoking and if a bar owner wants to permit smoking they should and the patron can make the choice to enter. A non smoker can drink at any restraunt bar without smoke. Keep if fair Phil.

    Posted By: Earned_My_Degree (11:11am 10-13-2008)
    Report Abuse


    How about an alternate hypothesis - the reason the revenues of the bars appears to be recovering is because many of them are now openly allowing smoking. It never fails to amaze me how some people jump to conclusions about results without doing the proper investigative reporting to find the facts. If you wanta find the facts, take a weekend and visit a dozen bars on Friday night and Saturday night and you might find the facts. Let's don't assume an influx of Putnam County patrons to Kanawha County bars, let's don't assume that Kanawha County bar patrons have simply accepting the edicts of the Health Board. Believe me, they have not accepted them. Take an opportunity, educate yourselves as to what is actually going in your community. The newspaper print a nice story and it's just that - a nice story.

    Posted By: weatherwatcher (10:25am 10-13-2008)
    Report Abuse


    Not really "great reporting" especially since the increase can be attributed to the publicity the bars have gotten due to ignoring the ban. In short, is the "success" due to rebounding business or defiance of the law and the publicity that entails? Give it a couple years AFTER the ban is actually enforced.

    Posted By: WVState (10:24am 10-13-2008)
    Report Abuse


    Does someone really think they need to damage the historic state capitol simply to run wires that are used ONE DAY A YEAR? There are plenty of professionals who can advise on updating a historic building without doing irreparable harm. Unfortunately, none of those work in the Dept of Administration.

    Advertiser

    It's easy to follow the top stories with home delivery of The Charleston Gazette.

    Click here to order home delivery.

    Advertiser
    More Politics
    High court's elimination of juvenile referees in court system criticized
    As news spread this week that the West Virginia Supreme Court had eliminated the position of juvenile referee, some judges and others questioned what that will mean for teenagers in the criminal justice system.
    Public comment period for vote-by-mail program
    West Virginia residents can comment on a state pilot project that will expand voting by mail in elections.
    McDowell delegate vows to stop traffic to protest tolls
    For at least one lawmaker, the fight over toll increases on the 88-mile West Virginia Turnpike is not over.
    West Virginia charitable pharmacy gets mail-order drug license
    A state board says a charitable pharmacy started by Gov. Joe Manchin has become the first of its type in the state to be licensed to ship mail-order prescriptions.
    Judge orders monitor on mental health issues
    The state will spend millions of dollars on new group homes, day treatment programs, jobs at psychiatric hospitals and other items associated with mental health care under an agreement reached Thursday.
    Carte Goodwin may run for Congress
    Carte Goodwin, general counsel for Gov. Joe Manchin during his first term between 2005 and 2009, is thinking about running for the congressional seat held by Rep. Shelley Moore Capito, R-W.Va., since 2000.
    New prisons, shorter sentences recommended to reduce Corrections system overcrowding
    A governor's commission submitted 14 short- and long-term recommendations to alleviate overcrowding in state prisons on Wednesday.
    W.Va. ends tough budget year on hopeful fiscal notes
    CHARLESTON, W.Va. -- West Virginia has ended its budget year with a trio of positive signs for state government's finances, but the recession and other factors overshadow each fiscal indicator.
    Turnpike toll hike approved
    For passenger vehicles, the hike means an increase from $1.25 to $2 per toll plaza, while the cash rate for commercial trucks will jump from $4.25 to $6.75 per toll plaza.
    Turnpike toll hike expected to pass Wednesday
    It's all but decided that the state Parkways Authority will approve toll increases on the West Virginia Turnpike on Wednesday. Still to be resolved are the amount of the increase, when it will take effect, and what sorts of discounts may be offered to Turnpike commuters.
    Manchin's energy plan among new July 1 laws
    BrickStreet Insurance repays state loan
    Ag department works to eliminate obsolete laws
    The state Department of Agriculture is working to get obsolete agriculture-related laws off the books.
    Byrd released from hospital after more than a month
    It's still not clear when the longest-serving senator in United States history might return to the Senate.
    Speakers blast proposed cut to state retiree benefits
    West Virginia will have trouble recruiting and retaining teachers, State Police troopers and other public employees if the Public Employees Insurance Agency cuts the subsidy, speakers said at a public hearing Monday evening.