August 10, 2008
Ex-private school employee alleges sexual innuendo, inappropriate contact
Advertiser

A former employee has sued top officials at a Summers County academy that houses 20 at-risk girls, claiming that she was subjected to sexual innuendo, an instructor had inappropriate physical contact with a student and she was fired without cause.

Lisa Sheffield, a former academic director at the Greenbrier Academy for Girls in Pence Springs, alleges in the lawsuit that she was fired the same day she planned to file a report on the school's clinical director, Ron Schwenkler.

Sheffield alleges that Schwenkler had "inappropriate physical contact" with a female student. She did not elaborate on the nature of the physical contact in her lawsuit, filed July 3 in U.S. District Court in Beckley.

Among those Sheffield sued are Greenbrier Academy founder L. Jay Mitchell; his son, chief operating officer Bart J. Mitchell; Schwenkler, who is L. Jay Mitchell's son-in-law, and Greenbrier headmaster and chief executive officer Matthew Hart.

Sheffield also alleges that she was promised a 401(k) retirement plan that she never received and she did not receive the medical, dental and life insurance benefits she was promised in a timely fashion.

In her complaint, she says a Greenbrier Academy employee notified her of inappropriate physical contact between Schwenkler and a student. On March 7, Sheffield told Hart that she intended to file an incident report in keeping with child abuse and neglect provisions of state law, according to the lawsuit.

It is unclear if Sheffield filed the incident report. Her attorney, R. Brandon Johnson of Lewisburg, did not return a follow-up phone message last week.

Later on March 7, Sheffield alleged that Hart and L. Jay Mitchell told her to remove her personal belongings and to not return to Greenbrier Academy, nor make any contact with faculty, staff, students or parents.

In an answer to Sheffield's complaint, the defendants deny Sheffield's claims, but acknowledge that she spoke to Hart about her allegations toward Schwenkler. They also said Sheffield was only told to return her work computer after she accepted another job.

In February, Sheffield was offered a full-time position at a private school in Maryland, according to her complaint.

On March 11, the defendants removed her profile from the Greenbrier Academy Web site and her professional credentials from an affiliated Web site, according to Sheffield's complaint.

She alleged that Bart Mitchell made unwanted and unwelcome sexual innuendo and comments of a sexual nature toward her. She also alleged that at various times during her employment, Schwenkler harassed her and was intimidating toward her.

In their answer, the defendants denied those allegations.

Report a violation or offensive comment.
[X] Close
to report abuse.
Posted By: something to hide (12:46am 08-12-2008)
Report Abuse


People and/or organizations who try to hide and supress complaints automatically look very guilty.

Posted By: Caution (11:00pm 08-11-2008)
Report Abuse


The best course of action in these cases is caution. Reporters don't always get the whole story, not because they don't want to, because they can't always track down every source of information. This doesn't excuse them but it is up to us, the readers, to understand that we will never know the whole story and exercise caution in filling in the gaps This employee who posted the comment should understand that when people hear about something like this, they will naturally be concerned. If this school is credible and there are positive things going on there it will become evident and concerns will be allayed. The school should welcome any type of investigation or report so that there would be no room for assumptions. If they did actually fire her knowing that she was about to file a complaint, it isn't the wisest of decisions. It seems they have employees like assumed and leaders like Hart who refuse to understand the need to report an allegations and in the end it will protect them.

Posted By: I remember (9:43pm 08-11-2008)
Report Abuse


Of course remember what they say about assuming is affiliated, just by what they posted it's easy to see, they have some inside information. The article states that Sheffield accepted other employment and was also fired, it seems a little unclear. Assuming well knows that educators, are MANDATED to report anything that even looks like inappropriate contact or abuse. Assuming is correct that CPS will dismiss a case when nothing is found however, this not remove an educators obligation to report an incident, often times educators and administrators report these possible incidents to protect, the school district and its employees. I find it sad that assuming didn't bother to read the article carefully, if this person had they would have read the words, claim and alleges. The article, nor any of the comments claim truth one way or the other. I hope that anyone reading this article and D. White realize the impact this can have on all parties and proceed accordingly.

Posted By: Even Chuck Doesn't Like It (4:58pm 08-11-2008)
Report Abuse


To Remember what they say about assuming,
It's not a "smear" to report abusive behavior. Anything positive done by the school doesn't negate abuse. And no, one source does not lead to the truth. Why doesn't the Academy report their version of events? Why didn't they release a statement? Are you affiliated with this academy?

Advertisement - Your ad here
Advertisement - Your ad here
ROUTE 21 DINER
Route 21 Diner (formerly Shotguns) is a family owned and run country restaurant. We're open for ...
Deal of the Day - ROUTE 21 DINER
10% off delivery orders
Advertisement - Your ad here