July 19, 2008
Smaller W.Va. hospitals get angioplasty approval
Manchin signs bill allowing heart procedures without cardiac surgeon on site
Page 2 of 2
Advertiser

Executives at the larger hospitals alleged that the community hospitals wouldn't have enough patients to maintain high-quality programs.

In 2002, the Health Care Authority approved three demonstration sites - Saint Francis, Weirton Medical Center and United Hospital Center in Clarksburg - to see whether heart catheterizations could be done without surgery backup. A consultant hired to evaluate programs gave them high marks.

The pilot programs are expected to request the state's permission to perform cardiac procedures on a permanent basis.

Thomas Memorial Hospital in South Charleston also plans to apply for approval.

"We've taken a very close look at data gathered over several years, and a number of other facts about the ability of our hospitals to perform heart angioplasty procedures that have the potential to save hundreds of lives, especially given our state's high heart disease rates and rural nature," Manchin said in a prepared release.

The standards come with stipulations. Hospitals that want to offer emergency angioplasties must perform at least 36 a year. And those that want to perform elective cardiac procedures must do at least 200 per year.

The standards became contentious because angioplasties are one of the few profit-making services that hospitals provide.

In recent weeks, larger hospitals have run advertisements urging Manchin to reject the new standards. Medium-size hospitals responded with ads encouraging him to approve the regulations. 

"This decision, in its entirety, is solely based on one objective," Manchin said, "to provide all of our citizens, regardless of their location, access to the best possible medical care in their time of need."

Reach Eric Eyre at erice...@wvgazette.com or 348-4869.

Report a violation or offensive comment.
[X] Close
to report abuse.
Posted By: Rebecca (8:22pm 07-19-2008)
Report Abuse


Steve makes some good points. Maybe that is why the American Heart Association, who has no finiancial interest and is simply concerned about quality of care, opposed angioplasty procedures at hospitals without onsite surgury.

Posted By: Steve from Sissonville (12:49am 07-19-2008)
Report Abuse


My brother in law had a catherization done at CAMC around 15 years ago and an artery ruptured. Their ability to perform an immediate bypass saved his life. Although the chances of this happening to you is extremely small, it's certainly not unheard of. Unfortunately, it seems that study results regarding the percentage of patients who require emergency heart surgery as a result of catherization/angioplasty complications are all over the map, with results always seeming to be skewed in the economic favor of whoever is funding the study (No surprise there!).
Does CAMC oppose this primarily because this ruling will negatively affect their bottom line? Probably!
Do the small hospitals support this because this ruling positively affects THEIR bottom line? You betcha!
Can medical consumers with life threating illnesses rely on medical hospitals and government to make decisions based solely of their medical needs without regards to profitability? NO WAY!!!

Posted By: Jackson (11:57am 07-19-2008)
Report Abuse


The Governor sided with these little hospitals solely for financial reasons - not because of what is best for patients. Shame on you Governor Manchin!

Anyone who has a heart cath performed at a hospital that lacks surgical back-up should have their head examined too - but these small hospitals can't do that properly either.

Posted By: Augustus (11:16am 07-19-2008)
Report Abuse


These afterhours clinics that some call hospitals have no business doing heart catheterizations. Raleigh General almost killed my mother a year ago with a heart catheterization. She was sent home the same day with orders to come back in two weeks for a follow up appointment. Oh, by the way, they couldn't do anything for her, so the point of the surgery was nothing!

She had a heartattack that night and was flown to CAMC, fortunately she survived.

Advertisement - Your ad here
Advertisement - Your ad here
SMITH'S CARPET ONE
When it comes to buying flooring for your home, there's only one flooring store to visit, Carpet...
Advertisement - Your ad here